State Records Committee Appeal Decision Summaries, 1998-2000
Follow case number link for full decision and order.
View decisions and orders from:
Search Decisions and Orders:
Case Number | Case Title/Participants | Records Sought | Ruling |
---|---|---|---|
98-01 | KSL vs. Juab County Sheriff's Dept. |
Jail booking photograph of James Penrod | Appeal granted |
98-02 | Ellis Dean Hovey vs. Utah Department of Human Services |
Address and telephone number of petitioner's son | Appeal granted |
98-03 | William T. Jacob vs. American Fork City |
Records concerning an investigation of the American Fork Police Department | Appeal denied |
98-04 | William T. Jacob vs. American Fork City |
A letter from former Mayor Jess Green to American Fork Police Chief John Durrant, regarding termination of Mr. Durrant's employment as Police Chief | Appeal denied |
98-05 | Michael A. Sims vs. Utah Education Network |
Logs regarding utilization of the Internet by students and school personnel of the public schools in Utah | Appeal granted |
98-06 | William T. Jacob vs. American Fork City |
Records of the investigation of the Police Department 'started by Councilmembers Storrs and McKinney' | Appeal denied |
98-07 | William T. Jacob vs. American Fork City |
Records of communications between a governmental entity and an attorney; attorney work product; and records that would reveal the contents of settlement negotiations | Appeal partially granted |
98-08 | George E. Brown, Jr. vs. American Fork City |
Various contact reports, supplemental police reports, witness statements, prosecutor notes; and correspondence related to the petitioner | Appeal partially granted |
98-09 | LINCOLN SMITH (Mustafa Abdul Aziz) vs. Utah Department of Corrections | Property confiscation forms | Appeal granted |
99-01 | Paul Knoll vs. Utah Department of Corrections |
List of all incoming, outgoing mail sent to or by petitioner | Appeal granted |
99-02 | Charles Watkins vs. Utah Department of Corrections |
All mental health records Appellee held regarding Appellant | Appeal denied |
99-03 | Leo T. Dirr vs. Weber State University |
Vote tallies and computer log server lists regarding a student election held at Weber State University | Appeal partially granted |
99-04 | Daniel T. Moquin vs. Utah Attorney General's Office |
A copy of the investigation relating to allegations of misconduct of certain other employees of Appellee | Appeal partially granted |
99-05 | Ernest Chacon vs. Utah Dept. of Corrections |
Portions of the investigative report of a certain 1988 incident at the Utah State Prison that reflect what the petitioner told the investigators | Appeal denied |
99-06 | Blaine Jordan vs. Division of Unclaimed Property Utah State Treasurer |
The dollar amount of each item of unclaimed property, described by Appellant as "the value of assets" | Appeal denied |
99-07 | Julian Hatch vs. Utah School Lands and Institutional Trust Administration |
All records between Chris Robinson and the Trust Lands Administration regarding Boulder property; Gibbs Smith's Application (and attachments) to Lease the subject property per a Trust Lands Administration letter to Appellant; and Smith's Request for Confidentiality of Business Records related to the Application | Appeal denied |
99-08 | Gregory T. Dunn vs. Tooele City |
Records of Appellee City that reflect claims against the City | Appeal granted |
99-09 | Mary Jean Meats vs. Logan City Police Department |
Personnel records of petitioner | Appeal partially granted |
99-10 | Taj N. Becker vs. Utah Dept. of Public Safety |
Education record(s)" and "employment record(s)" of a certain named employee of Appellee | Appeal denied |
99-11 | David E. Schlottman vs. Dept. of Commerce |
All records including secret records in petitioner's file | Appeal denied |
99-12 | Suzanne Pape vs. Utah Dept. of Public Safety |
All pre-internal affairs investigation documents requested by [Appellant] and all documents not created or maintained for the internal affairs investigation pertaining to Appellee's investigation of Appellant | Appeal denied |
99-13 | Penny Atkinson vs. City of West Jordan |
Report prepared by Appellee regarding allegations of impropriety brought against petitioner by a co-employee | Appeal denied |
99-14 | Barbara Haynes vs. Logan City Police Dept. |
Grievance tapes of a hearing between petitioner and her supervisor, petitioner's department file and a copy of the Noise Survey Results conducted as a result of [petitioner's] hearing loss | Appeal declared moot |
99-15 | Cathy Cartwright vs. Utah Dept. of Corrections |
Copies of the completed criteria forms for the two CA II positions and the one CA IV position and copies of the completed CA Interview Notes for those same positions | Appeal granted |
00-01 | DataLister, Inc. vs. Utah Labor Commission |
Names of employers required by law to be reported by insurers employers to the State; each such employer's address; each employer's insurer of record; and each employer's insurance policy renewal date | Appeal denied |
00-02 | Roger Humphries vs. Washington County School District |
Two psychological evaluations prepared by doctors who examined Appellant in connection with Appellee's notice of intent to terminate employment | Appeal denied |
00-03 | Matt Barlow dba Network Electric
Inc. vs. Dept. of Commerce |
Investigation policy and procedure manual maintained by the Department's Division of Occupational & Professional Licensing | Appeal granted |
none | Mark D. Bergman vs. Labor Commission |
Five documents by the Labor Commission which petitioner alleges contained his private information | Findings of fact only |
00-04 | Robot Aided Manufacturing Center,
Inc. dba Explore Information Services vs. Utah Dept. of Public Safety, Division of Driver License |
Motor vehicle record information |
Appeal granted Utah Court of Appeals overturned Committee's ruling-May 2005 |
00-05 | Wasatch County Courier, LLC vs. Wasatch County (Utah) |
Billing records relating to payments by the County to outside counsel Joseph Dunbeck | Appeal granted |
00-06 | Kristin M. Cappel vs. University of Utah |
Skiing file records, including e-mails and handwritten notes; a self-report to the NCAA; and Initial Academic Eligibility Waiver Applications | Appeal denied |
00-07 | William Munro vs. Utah Dept. of Corrections |
Nine column employee list/roster | Appeal denied |
00-08 | Deseret News vs. Utah State Tax Commission |
Tax lien information on property of candidates seeking public office | Appeal denied |
00-09 | Adrian Hickey vs. Board of Pardons and Parole |
All public decisions and rational sheets that the Board has issued to offenders that came before them on parole hearings | Appeal denied |
00-10 | People for the USA, Color Country
Chapter vs. Kane County |
The complete road agreement between the Bureau of Land Management in Kane County, including all supporting documents; minutes from several meetings; current plats and specific descriptions of all county roads existing in Kane County; and a second written opinion from Steve Boyden of the Utah Attorney General's Office concerning the aforementioned road agreement | Appeal granted |
00-11 | Jess Green vs. American Fork City | All records faxed from American Fork City to private Attorney Kathryn Collard, and received from that attorney | Appeal denied |
Page Last Updated January 31, 2022 .