State Records Committee Appeal Decision Summaries, 2001-2003
Follow the case number link for the full decision and order.
View decisions and orders from:
Search Decisions and Orders:
Case Number | Case Title/Participants | Records Sought | Ruling |
---|---|---|---|
01-01 | Gordon Thomas vs. Utah Dept. of Corrections | List of sex offenders currently housed in the prison | Appeal dismissed |
01-02 | Associated Press vs. Utah Attorney General's Office | Information gathered by the Attorney General during an investigation of the bidding for the 2002 Olympic Winter Games | Appeal granted |
01-03 | Adrian Hickey vs. Utah Dept. of Corrections | Petitioner's strip cell logs and recreation out-of-cell-time logs; and also copies of twenty-four (24) Utah Department of Corrections contracts | Appeal denied |
01-04 | Michael John Bixby vs. Dept. of Admin. Service-Division of Risk Management | All reports, accident reports, letters, memorandum, and other documents produced or maintained by the Utah Department of Corrections regarding the automobile accident of a prisoner transport van | Appeal denied |
01-05 | Barbara Schwarz vs. Dept. of Human Services-Division of Mental Health | All records pertaining to petitioner | Appeal granted |
01-06 | U.S. Chamber of Commerce and U.S. Chamber Institute for Legal Reform vs. Utah Attorney General's Office | Documents pertaining to the selection of outside counsel to represent the State of Utah in tobacco litigation |
Appeal granted |
01-07 | Colorado Legal Services vs. Utah Dept. of Agriculture | Fee waiver | Appeal denied |
01-08 | Mary Jean Meats vs. Logan City | Copy of a dog license petitioner issued while a city employee; documentation regarding a complaint she made against Amber Anderson for allegedly accessing "a secured police building through the security rear entrance door"; copies of "all investigations rendered on me"; copies of all documents related to a sexual harassment complaint made against her supervisor, including notes of Mark Sorensen, City Attorney; a "complete copy of the Garrity rules and regulations"; and a copy of notes taken by Sgt. Eric Collins "that were made when he was a witness when [Mrs. Meats] filed with Lt. Earl a request for religious accommodation | Appeal partially granted |
01-09 | William Jacob vs. American Fork City | Records pertaining to commissions paid to Tom Hunter and/or Hunter & Associates by third parties and any documentation of services rendered by Mr. Hunter and/or his firm "to every City department on every Wednesday of each week" | Appeal denied |
01-10 | Packaging Corp. of America vs. Utah Labor Commission | copy of an OSHA complaint file, number 201550514 | Appeal granted |
01-11 | William Jacob vs. American Fork City | Records pertaining to American Fork City's August 1997 request for proposals (RFP) for employee benefit consulting services | Appeal granted |
02-01 | Brent Poll vs. South Weber City | Minutes from a closed meeting |
Appeal denied |
02-02 | Robert Rice vs. Utah Dept. of Corrections | Prison policies and procedures concerning inmate and visitor management and security, including searches and involuntary medical treatment | Appeal denied |
02-03 | Michael T. McCoy vs. Utah Attorney General's Office | Copies of the contract or contracts between the State of Utah and/or the Utah Attorney General's Office and the law firm of Ray, Quinney & Nebeker in which the law firm agrees to provide legal representation in the cases styled Utah Education Association et al, vs. Michael Leavitt, et al | Appeal granted |
02-04 | Harold Sersland vs. Dept. of Natural Resources-Div. of Wildlife Resources | Data on "guzzler" locations in the Dugway and Thomas mountain ranges of Tooele and Juab counties |
Appeal denied |
02-05 | Disability Law Center vs. Utah Transit Authority | Records concerning wheelchairs and scooters using respondent's paratransit service | Appeal granted |
02-06 | Mr. Pooper Scooper, Inc. vs. Murray and Sandy City | Home addresses of licensed dog owners | Appeal denied |
02-07 | Brent Poll vs. South Weber City | Legal opinions of South Weber City's attorney concerning a proposal regarding 1375 East and the City's decision regarding that proposal | Appeal denied |
02-08 | Adrian Hickey vs. Dept of Corrections | Photographs which were taken of petitioner's tattoos while housed in the prison's Uinta II facility | Appeal denied |
02-09 | Albert Cramer vs. Murray City | Child witness interview transcripts, police department policies and other documents petitioner believes pertained to his criminal cases | Appeal denied |
02-10 | Mark Powell vs. Lehi City | Visual and/or audio records of petitioner's visit to the Lehi library 23 Aug 02, including interactions with staff | Appeal denied |
03-01 | Darren C. Bluemel vs. Dept. of Public Safety | Petitioner's DNA profile maintained by the Department of Public Safety | Appeal granted |
03-02 | Douglas D. Jones vs. Dept. of Human Services, Office of Recovery Services | All communications between O.R.S. and their legal counsel; all records that show ownership of property, business, stocks, bonds or title to any thing with a monetary value; and all protected and non-protected government information in petitioner's file | Appeal denied |
03-03 | Kevin Tolton vs. Town of Alta | Various records petitioner maintains are in the Town of Alta's possession | Appeal partially granted |
03-04 | Inner City Press, Community on the Move & Fair Finance Watch vs. Utah Attorney General | Records related to the recent settlement with Household International, Inc. | Appeal denied |
03-05 | Brent Poll vs. South Weber City | Records relating to a city council presentation from U.S. Development concerning a potential land transaction involving the city and that company | Appeal granted |
03-06 | Sean Timothy Hughes vs. Utah Dept. of Corrections | Audio tapes made during nine disciplinary hearings | Appeal granted |
03-07 | Kevin Tolton vs. Town of Alta | Various documents petitioner maintains are, or should be, in the Town of Alta's possession | Appeal partly granted |
03-08 | Ricardo Rodriguez vs. Utah Board of Pardons and Parole | Documents used by the Board of Pardons and Parole (the "Board") in petitioner's recent re-determination hearing | Appeal denied |
03-09 | Robin C. Boon vs. Utah Transit Authority | Handwritten notes of Lorin Simpson and "other documents prepared by Lorin Simpson and Nancy Malecker" concerning appellant's 2002 performance review | Appeal granted |
03-10 | Frank Medel, Jr. vs. Utah Dept. of Public Safety |
All written reports generated by the Utah State Crime Lab in the analysis of physical evidence of specific incidents | Appeal denied |
03-11 | Jeff Iverson vs. West Bountiful City |
Payroll information about the city manager. | Appeal partly granted |
Page Last Updated January 31, 2022 .