State Records Committee Appeal Decision Summaries, 2004-2006
Follow the case number link for the full decision and order.
View decisions and orders from:
Search Decisions and Orders:
|Case Number||Case Title/Participants||Records Sought||Ruling|
|04-01||Jeremy Beckham vs.
University of Utah
|All approved protocols for all approved research currently utilizing baboons or macaques||Appeal partly granted|
|04-02||Brian K. Stack vs.
Utah Dept. of Corrections
|Offender Management Review Committee results regarding prisoners referred to OMR for communicating with women prisoners||Appeal denied|
|04-03||William Jacob vs.
American Fork City
|Records of any investigation conducted by the mayor or city council concerning the qualifications of any candidate for office||Appeal denied|
|04-04||Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance and
the Wilderness Society vs.
Utah State Attorney General
|Records concerning potential applications for recordable disclaimers of interest for Utah roads, specifically R.S. 2477 rights of way||Appeal partially granted|
|04-05||Paul Payne vs.
Utah Dept. of Corrections
|Employee list/personel roster||Appeal denied|
|04-06||Victor Orvis vs.
Pleasant Grove City
|All lists created by [Pleasant Grove] City personnel involving all businesses or persons who were mailed or otherwise received [Carol Emery's July 19, 2001] letter regarding business license enforcement||Appeal partly granted|
|04-07||Larry Vernon vs.
|The taped recording parts of Coalville City Council Meetings referred to in the available minutes of City Coucil Executive Session meetings.||Appeal denied|
|04-08||Lisa Olsen vs. Utah Department of Human Services||Qualitative Case Review on Jesse Olsen||Appeal denied|
|04-09||Jeremy Beckham vs. University of Utah||A fee waiver for the fees associated with producing all approved protocols for all research currently utilizing baboons and/or macaques.||Appeal denied|
|04-10||Steven Onysko vs. University of Utah||Final Grade Report for MG EN 499, Fall Quarter 1995.||Appeal denied|
|04-11||Haik vs. Town of Alta||The Town of Alta to permit inspection during normal business hours and require the Town of Alta to timely respond to pending records requests.||Appeal partly granted|
|04-12||LaPlante/Canham (Salt Lake Tribune) vs. Sandy City||The names of all current Sandy City fire and police employees.||Appeal granted|
|04-13||Collier Hoffman vs. Division of Occupational and Professional Licensing||Any investigations/complaint information regarding Jo-Anne Collier Hoffman.||Appeal dismissed|
|04-14||Poll vs. South Weber City||Access to draft minutes of the August 26, 2004 South Weber City Planning Commission meeting.||Appeal Denied|
|04-15||Haik vs. Town of Alta (noncompliance)||Sanctions for the Town's noncompliance with the Order and Decision dated September 21, 2004.||Appeal granted|
|04-16||LaPlante (Salt Lake Tribune) vs. Salt Lake City Police Department||All initial reports from a 'missing person' case inolving Lori Kay Hacking, filed on or about July 19, 2004" and "all initial reports involving suspect, victim or involved person Mark Douglas Hacking.||Appeal Denied|
|04-17||Steed vs. Duchesne County||Access to various documents he believes are in Duchesne County's possession.||Appeal granted|
|05-01||Ostler vs. State of Utah, Departments of Public Safety, Commerce, Human Resource Management, Human Services, Attorney General's Office, Labor Commission, and Salt Lake Community College||Access to various documents referencing his name that he believes are in the custody of the various agencies of the State of Utah.||Appeal Denied|
|05-02||Salt Lake City Corporation vs. Salt Lake Mayor's Records Appeals Board||Salt Lake City Corporation appeals the decision of the Salt Lake City Mayor's Records Appeals Board granting access to certain records requested by Neal K. Ostler.||Appeal partly granted|
|05-03||LaPlante/Canham (Salt Lake Tribune) vs. Sandy City||Records pertaining to overtime and bonuses paid to Sandy City's police and fire department personnel.||Appeal granted|
|05-04||Schwarz vs. University of Utah||Any records on Barbara Schwarz or Schwartz, Mark C. Rathbun, Mark de Rothschild, Scientology, Church of Scientology, L. Ron Hubbard, and Dwight David Eisenhower.||Appeal Denied|
|05-05||Wells vs. Pleasant Grove City||Various records which relate to a citation received for allegedly electioneering within 150 feet of a polling place.||Appeal Denied|
|05-06||Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance vs. Automated Geographic Reference Center||Records concerning [certain] roads/routes located in Emery County.||
Ruling reversed by Utah Supreme Court case
|05-07||Whitney vs. Department of Corrections||Access to grievances that inmates filed against him in November 2004 and the "level 1, level 2, level 3 responses" to the grievance.||Appeal Denied|
|05-08||Schwaar vs. Department of Corrections||A copy of his diagnostic report.||Appeal denied|
|05-09||Payne vs. Department of Corrections||A copy of the Uinta 1 Inmate Roster for the date of 8-4-05.||Appeal denied|
|06-01||Tribune vs. Governor's Office||The names of companies promised monetary incentives by the State of Utah, as well as e-mail correspondence between the GOED employees, GOED board members and company officials relating to these specific incentive awards.||Appeal partly granted|
|Certain pages of a Board of Pardons document entitled "Hearing Worksheet" which contains various details about his personal history and sentence being served at the Utah State Prison||Appeal partly granted|
|06-03||Spectrum vs. Washington City||All lawyers fees that were and are associated with the Cloud Moving and Storage vs. Washington City lawsuit.||Appeal Granted|
|06-04||Treff vs. Utah Tax Commission||A copy of the 2004 and 2005 state tax returns filed by Mormons for Equality and Social Justice.||Appeal Denied|
|06-05||Salt Lake Tribune vs. Salt Lake Police Dept. Civilian Review Board
||Personnel performance evaluations and disciplinary actions||Appeal Partially Granted|
|06-06||Monique Crowley vs. Sandy City
||Records regarding personnel matters, and dismissal action against Monique Crowley||Appeal Denied|
|06-07||Deborah Langdon vs. Utah Dept. of Human Services
||Fatality review reports||Appeal Granted|
|06-08||Joycelyn Straight vs. Lieutenant Governor's Office
||Records of Utah voter registrations, and a fee waiver for those records||Appeal Partially Granted|
|06-09||Bruce Funk vs. Emery County
||Records of executive sessions held by the Emery County Commission||Appeal Denied|
|06-10||Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance vs Division of Oil, Gas, and Mining||Fee waiver for records||Appeal Denied|
|06-11||William H. Doutis, Jr. vs. Dept. of Corrections
||Records associated with his correctional history held by the Dept. of Corrections, plus a waiver of fees.||Appeal Denied|
|06-12||Karl Dee Kay vs. Dept. of Corrections||Polygraph, "C" notes, and treatment notes||Appeal Denied|