State Records Committee Appeal Decision Summaries, 2019

 

Follow the case number link for the full decision and order.

View decisions and orders from:

Search Decisions and Orders:

Case Number Case Title/Participants Records Sought Ruling
19-01 Scott Gollaher vs.
Morgan County
Records relating to Certificates of Insurance, payments and/or invoices and/or any accounting records relating to specific persons doing business with Respondent, Morgan County. Order of Continuance
19-02 Janae Wahnschaffe vs.
Highland City
Correspondences to and from specific individuals including the mayor of Highland City, copies of investigative written reports, signed affidavits, a presentation given during a board meeting, and copies of outgoing text messages from a specific person. Appeal Granted
19-03 Scott Gollaher vs.
Morgan County
Records relating to Certificates of Insurance, payments and/or invoices and/or any accounting records relating to specific persons doing business with Respondent, Morgan County. Appeal Denied
19-04 Brady Eames vs.
West Valley City
Any and all executed and filed public official penal bonds and any and all subscribed and filed constitutional oaths of office of certain elected and appointed officers. Appeal Denied
19-05 Brady Eames vs.
Ogden City
Any and all executed and filed public official penal bonds and any and all subscribed and filed constitutional oaths of office of certain elected and appointed officers. Appeal Denied
19-06 Edward A. Berkovich vs.
Utah Attorney General's Office
The “freeconferencecall.com” recording of a Utah Prosecution Council (UPC) Board meeting held on October 21, 2015 to discuss the “character, professional competence, or physical or mental health” of the petitioner and his continued employment with UPC. Appeal Denied
19-07 Brady Eames vs.
Utah Local Government Trust
Numerous emails to/from specific individuals relating to Respondent. Appeal Denied
19-08 Taylor Stevens, Salt Lake Tribune vs.
Grantsville City
Any and all documents and final reports pertaining to the outside investigation into Mayor Brent Marshall’s behavior. Appeal Partially Granted
19-09 Anthony Fierro vs.
Salt Lake School District
Records allegedly held by respondent. Order of Continuance
19-10 Chad Benion vs.
Utah Attorney General's Office
All records demonstrating costs, fees, charges or payment, incurred by the Attorney General's Office in any litigation regarding Senate Bill 54 (2014). Appeal Denied
19-11 Janalee Raelynn Roberts vs.
Utah Department of Human Services. Division of Child and Family Services
Final reports for DCFS Case numbers 2446067 or 244758, and for records related to an interview conducted by the Children’s Justice Center on July 12, 2018 including the final report findings. Appeal Denied
19-12 Douglas Sagers vs.
Tooele County
County audited and unaudited financial records, budges, contracts, management agreements, leases, purchase orders, invoices for equipment, O&M, vehicles, marketing, operating supplies, restaurant furnishings and equipment, ATVS, computers, contracts and agreements entered into between Tooele County and lessees, managers, contractors, consultants, professional service providers, appraisers, and or other parties involved or retained by Tooele County to manage, assist, consult, or advise Tooele County in the operation and or sale of the Tooele County Owned Utah Motorsports Park. Appeal Granted
19-13 Eric Peterson vs.
Utah Attorney General's Office
Records allegedly held by Respondent, the Utah Attorney General’s Office. Order of Continuance
19-14 Judith Zimmerman vs.
Utah Attorney General's Office
Any and all documentation of disciplinary action taken against four individuals who were current or former employees of the AG’s Office. Appeal Denied
19-15 Bill Keshlear vs.
San Juan County
Records related to a meeting of the San Juan County Commission on February 5, 2019. Appeal Granted
19-16 Joshua Althoff vs.
Moab City
An Internal Affairs Investigation Report in its entirety, including polygraph reports and recordings. Appeal Partially Granted
19-17 Tony Alexander Hamilton vs.
Utah Department of Corrections
The contract between the UDC and the contract attorneys, Wayne Freestone and David Angerhofer. Appeal Denied
19-18 Seven Wilson vs.
Tooele City
All supplements [sic], investigative reports, narrative statements, opening statements, D.N.A results, and discoveries for a specific case. Appeal Denied
19-19 Michael Bacon vs.
Utah Deparment of Corrections
Policy that governs that allows inmates to send out urine analysis to an outside independent lab to be re-tested. Appeal Denied
19-20 Elias Faraclas vs.
Lehi City
The TMTH Development Agreement and all records relating to the Agreement between January 16, 2018 and the signing of the Agreement. Appeal Granted
19-21 Eric Peterson vs.
Utah Attorney General's Office
  Order of Continuance

Previous Page

Page Last Updated July 22, 2019.