Decisions & Orders

State Records Committee

Outcomes After Appeal Hearings

The State Records Committee issues the decisions and orders after appeal hearings have been held. Below you’ll find a table of all decisions, sorted in newest-first order. Click the Chronological Key header to sort by oldest-first order.

Chronological KeyLink to CasesCase Title/ParticipantsRecords SoughtRulingCourt CaseCourt Links
1https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=92-0192-01Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Dept. of TransportationTraffic accident databaseAppeal partially granted
2https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=92-0292-02Deseret News vs. Utah Dept. of Public Safety, Driver's License DivisionDriving records [fee waiver]Appeal denied
3https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=93-0193-01Randy T. Nielsen vs. Utah Dept. of Natural ResourcesHunting and fishing licensesAppeal granted
4https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=93-0293-02John Pace vs. Dept. of CorrectionsMonitoring of inmate phone callsAppeal granted
5https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=93-0393-03James N. Haywood vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsRecords relating to criminal chargesAppeal denied
6https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=93-0493-04Sue Cherry vs. Utah State UniversityTenure retention recordsAppeal granted
7https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=93-0593-05Kenneth L. Gray vs. Dept. of Human ResourcesRecords regarding a meetingAppeal denied
8https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=93-0693-06Equifax Services, Inc. vs. Utah Dept. of Public Safety, Driver's License DivisionDrivers license databaseAppeal granted
9https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=93-0793-07ACLU vs. O. Lane McCotter, executive director of the Utah Dept. of CorrectionsInformation regarding new inmate phone systemAppeal denied
10https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-0194-01Karl William Winsness vs. Salt Lake City CorporationPolice "no knock - no announce warrants," "high risk arrests and searches," and "major incident responses."Appeal denied
11https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-0294-02Julian Dean Hatch vs. Utah State Div. of Parks and RecreationRecords regarding archeological digs and research done at Coombs site, Anasazi State ParkAppeal denied
12https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-0394-03Salt Lake City vs. Utah Dept. of Employment SecurityNumber of employees for each businessAppeal granted
13https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-0494-04Deseret News vs. University of UtahCold fusion licensing documentsAppeal denied
14https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-0594-05Linda A. Watson vs. Utah Dept. of Human Services, Offices of Liability ManagementResolution Assistance Committee report regarding petitioner's minor childrenAppeal partially granted
15https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-0694-06Michael R. Weibel vs. Logan CityPolice report and city agreementAppeal partially granted
16https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-0794-07Linda A. Watson vs Utah Dept. of Human Resources, Division of Family ServicesRecords relating to petitioner's childrenAppeal denied
17https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-0894-08William Remine vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsPolicies, a list of inmates, and a list of staffAppeal partially granted
18https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-0994-09Sassy M. Fink and KSTU vs. Utah State HospitalMedical records and investigation records of an injury-causing incidentAppeal partially granted
19https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-1094-10William Remine vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsRecords regarding Appellant that are classified as "protected."Appeal denied
20https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-1194-11William Remine vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsRecords of the Board of Pardons regarding Appellant that are classified as "protected."Appeal denied
21https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-1294-12Abigail W. Delfausse vs. Utah State UniversityAppellant's personnel file classified "protected."Appeal granted
22https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-1394-13United Television Inc., a Delaware Corporation, aba KTVX Channel 4 vs. Board of Pardons and ParoleVideo tape regarding assault of Howard W. HunterAppeal denied
23https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-1494-14Thomas R. Garcia vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsFee waiver for medical recordsAppeal granted
24https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-1594-15Linda A. Watson vs. Utah Dept. of Human Services, Division of Family ServicesTwo letters from Dr. Kevin Gully (a supervising therapist for minor children of petitioner) and a complete unredacted letter of a third party.Appeal denied
25https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-1694-16Salt Lake City vs. Industrial Commission of UtahRecords relating to LaMar C. Macklin in the Matter of LaMar C. Macklin v. Salt Lake City Corporation before the UADDAppeal granted
26https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=94-1794-17Roger E. Penman vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsSupplemental Reports and Investigative Reports concerning a disciplinary caseAppeal denied
27https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=95-0195-01Clifton W. Panos vs. Utah State Tax CommissionFilings in the case before Appellant Commission, identified as Appeal # 94-1317, World-Wide Men's Missionary Fellowship, petitioner -- Salt Lake County Board of Equalization, respondentAppeal granted
28https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=95-0295-02L. Chris Carter vs. University of UtahPatient schedules, patient care plans and hemo dialysis flow sheetsAppeal granted with limitations
29https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=95-0395-03Walter E. Brantzeg vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsPsychological Results from Personality Inventories, and I.Q. tests given by the Prison or Medical/Psychology departmentAppeal denied
30https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=95-0495-04Stephen E. Hughes vs. Utah Division of InvestigationAll records relating to AppellantAppeal denied
31https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=95-0595-05Lance T. Wilkerson vs. Auditing Division, Utah State Tax CommissionManuals, policy statements and other materials on the conduct of audits in general and not as to any specific auditAppeal partially granted
32https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=95-0695-06Herald Journal vs. Utah State UniversityCopies of contracts Appellee has with Larry Eustachy and John L. SmithAppeal granted
33https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=95-0795-07A-1 Disposal vs. Davis County Solid Waste Management and Energy Recovery Special Service DistrictRecords regarding haulers of wasteAppeal granted
34https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=95-0895-08Dolores Ruvalcaba vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsMedical and prison records of Edward LujanAppeal granted
35https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=95-0995-09Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Division of Risk ManagementDocuments pertaining to the claims reflected on [an] attached list ... including but not limited to, claim forms or any other paperwork filed pertaining to the claims, and any and all settlement documentsAppeal denied
36https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=95-1095-10Kim and Nancy Julian, Philip and Ram Roundy vs. University of Utah Medical Center and Intermountain Tissue CenterPolicies relating to the production of documents pursuant to GRAMA; records of treatment and care provided for Spencer Roundy and Kevin Julian; and information regarding pericardial implants and tissuesAppeal granted
37https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=96-0196-01Paul Harris vs. Div. of Occupational and Professional Licensing, Utah Dept. of CommerceThree complaints, including names signatures, addresses and phone numbersAppeal denied
38https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=96-0296-02Robert O. Strange vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsInformation related to a background investigation of PetitionerAppeal denied
39https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=96-0396-03Michael Brian Whiteman vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsCopy of the IR1 form that is in the petitioner's file regarding a certain disciplinary matterAppeal denied
40https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=96-0496-04Walter J. Thomas vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsMedical and psychological records pertaining to PetitionerAppeal denied
41https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=97-0197-01Gregory M. Bedard vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsAll policies in the A and F manuals of Policies and Procedures of RespondentAppeal granted with conditions
42https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=97-0297-02Society of Professional Journalists vs. Utah State Board of RegentsRecords containing personally-identifiable information related to the University of Utah presidential search applicants or nomineesAppeal denied
43https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=97-0397-03Joseph W. O'Keefe vs. Utah State Retirement SystemsRecords related to the base number of work hours per week for firefighters for purposes of the State Retirement System and related to lobbying on behalf on the Retirement SystemsAppeal denied
44https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=98-0198-01KSL vs. Juab County Sheriff's Dept.Jail booking photograph of James PenrodAppeal granted
45https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=98-0298-02Ellis Dean Hovey vs. Utah Department of Human ServicesAddress and telephone number of petitioner's sonAppeal granted
46https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=98-0398-03William T. Jacob vs. American Fork CityRecords concerning an investigation of the American Fork Police DepartmentAppeal denied
47https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=98-0498-04William T. Jacob vs. American Fork CityA letter from former Mayor Jess Green to American Fork Police Chief John Durrant, regarding termination of Mr. Durrant's employment as Police ChiefAppeal denied
48https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=98-0598-05Michael A. Sims vs. Utah Education NetworkLogs regarding utilization of the Internet by students and school personnel of the public schools in UtahAppeal granted
49https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=98-0698-06William T. Jacob vs. American Fork CityRecords of the investigation of the Police Department 'started by Councilmembers Storrs and McKinney'Appeal denied
50https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=98-0798-07William T. Jacob vs. American Fork CityRecords of communications between a governmental entity and an attorney; attorney work product; and records that would reveal the contents of settlement negotiationsAppeal partially granted
51https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=98-0898-08George E. Brown, Jr. vs. American Fork CityVarious contact reports, supplemental police reports, witness statements, prosecutor notes; and correspondence related to the petitionerAppeal partially granted
52https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=98-0998-09LINCOLN SMITH (Mustafa Abdul Aziz) vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsProperty confiscation formsAppeal granted
53https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-0199-01Paul Knoll vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsList of all incoming, outgoing mail sent to or by petitionerAppeal granted
54https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-0299-02Charles Watkins vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAll mental health records Appellee held regarding AppellantAppeal denied
55https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-0399-03Leo T. Dirr vs. Weber State UniversityVote tallies and computer log server lists regarding a student election held at Weber State UniversityAppeal partially granted
56https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-0499-04Daniel T. Moquin vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeA copy of the investigation relating to allegations of misconduct of certain other employees of AppelleeAppeal partially granted
57https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-0599-05Ernest Chacon vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsPortions of the investigative report of a certain 1988 incident at the Utah State Prison that reflect what the petitioner told the investigatorsAppeal denied
58https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-0699-06Blaine Jordan vs. Division of Unclaimed Property Utah State TreasurerThe dollar amount of each item of unclaimed property, described by Appellant as "the value of assets"Appeal denied
59https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-0799-07Julian Hatch vs. Utah School Lands and Institutional Trust AdministrationAll records between Chris Robinson and the Trust Lands Administration regarding Boulder property; Gibbs Smith's Application (and attachments) to Lease the subject property per a Trust Lands Administration letter to Appellant; and Smith's Request for Confidentiality of Business Records related to the ApplicationAppeal denied
60https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-0899-08Gregory T. Dunn vs. Tooele CityRecords of Appellee City that reflect claims against the CityAppeal granted
61https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-0999-09Mary Jean Meats vs. Logan City Police DepartmentPersonnel records of petitionerAppeal partially granted
62https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-1099-10Taj N. Becker vs. Utah Dept. of Public SafetyEducation record(s)" and "employment record(s)" of a certain named employee of AppelleeAppeal denied
63https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-1199-11David E. Schlottman vs. Dept. of CommerceAll records including secret records in petitioner's fileAppeal denied
64https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-1299-12Suzanne Pape vs. Utah Dept. of Public SafetyAll pre-internal affairs investigation documents requested by [Appellant] and all documents not created or maintained for the internal affairs investigation pertaining to Appellee's investigation of AppellantAppeal denied
65https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-1399-13Penny Atkinson vs. City of West JordanReport prepared by Appellee regarding allegations of impropriety brought against petitioner by a co-employeeAppeal denied
66https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-1499-14Barbara Haynes vs. Logan City Police Dept.Grievance tapes of a hearing between petitioner and her supervisor, petitioner's department file and a copy of the Noise Survey Results conducted as a result of [petitioner's] hearing lossAppeal declared moot
67https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=99-1599-15Cathy Cartwright vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsCopies of the completed criteria forms for the two CA II positions and the one CA IV position and copies of the completed CA Interview Notes for those same positionsAppeal granted
68https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=00-0100-01DataLister, Inc. vs. Utah Labor CommissionNames of employers required by law to be reported by insurers employers to the State; each such employer's address; each employer's insurer of record; and each employer's insurance policy renewal dateAppeal denied
69https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=00-0200-02Roger Humphries vs. Washington County School DistrictTwo psychological evaluations prepared by doctors who examined Appellant in connection with Appellee's notice of intent to terminate employmentAppeal denied
70https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=00-0300-03Matt Barlow dba Network Electric Inc. vs. Dept. of CommerceInvestigation policy and procedure manual maintained by the Department's Division of Occupational & Professional LicensingAppeal granted
71https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=nonenoneMark D. Bergman vs. Labor CommissionFive documents by the Labor Commission which petitioner alleges contained his private informationFindings of fact only
72https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=00-0400-04Robot Aided Manufacturing Center, Inc. dba Explore Information Services vs. Utah Dept. of Public Safety, Division of Driver LicenseMotor vehicle record informationAppeal grantedUtah Court of Appeals overturned Committee's ruling-May 2005https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=3675185435661997452&q=Robot+Aided+Manufacturing+Center&hl=en&as_sdt=4,45
73https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=00-0500-05Wasatch County Courier, LLC vs. Wasatch County (Utah)Billing records relating to payments by the County to outside counsel Joseph DunbeckAppeal granted
74https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=00-0600-06Kristin M. Cappel vs. University of UtahSkiing file records, including e-mails and handwritten notes; a self-report to the NCAA; and Initial Academic Eligibility Waiver ApplicationsAppeal denied
75https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=00-0700-07William Munro vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsNine column employee list/rosterAppeal denied
76https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=00-0800-08Deseret News vs. Utah State Tax CommissionTax lien information on property of candidates seeking public officeAppeal denied
77https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=00-0900-09Adrian Hickey vs. Board of Pardons and ParoleAll public decisions and rational sheets that the Board has issued to offenders that came before them on parole hearingsAppeal denied
78https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=00-1000-10People for the USA, Color Country Chapter vs. Kane CountyThe complete road agreement between the Bureau of Land Management in Kane County, including all supporting documents; minutes from several meetings; current plats and specific descriptions of all county roads existing in Kane County; and a second written opinion from Steve Boyden of the Utah Attorney General's Office concerning the aforementioned road agreementAppeal granted
79https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=00-1100-11Jess Green vs. American Fork CityAll records faxed from American Fork City to private Attorney Kathryn Collard, and received from that attorneyAppeal denied
80https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=01-0101-01Gordon Thomas vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsList of sex offenders currently housed in the prisonAppeal dismissed
81https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=01-0201-02Associated Press vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeInformation gathered by the Attorney General during an investigation of the bidding for the 2002 Olympic Winter GamesAppeal granted
82https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=01-0301-03Adrian Hickey vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsPetitioner's strip cell logs and recreation out-of-cell-time logs; and also copies of twenty-four (24) Utah Department of Corrections contractsAppeal denied
83https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=01-0401-04Michael John Bixby vs. Dept. of Admin. Service-Division of Risk ManagementAll reports, accident reports, letters, memorandum, and other documents produced or maintained by the Utah Department of Corrections regarding the automobile accident of a prisoner transport vanAppeal denied
84https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=01-0501-05Barbara Schwarz vs. Dept. of Human Services-Division of Mental HealthAll records pertaining to petitionerAppeal granted
85https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=01-0601-06U.S. Chamber of Commerce and U.S. Chamber Institute for Legal Reform vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeDocuments pertaining to the selection of outside counsel to represent the State of Utah in tobacco litigationAppeal granted
86https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=01-0701-07Colorado Legal Services vs. Utah Dept. of AgricultureFee waiverAppeal denied
87https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=01-0801-08Mary Jean Meats vs. Logan CityCopy of a dog license petitioner issued while a city employee; documentation regarding a complaint she made against Amber Anderson for allegedly accessing "a secured police building through the security rear entrance door"; copies of "all investigations rendered on me"; copies of all documents related to a sexual harassment complaint made against her supervisor, including notes of Mark Sorensen, City Attorney; a "complete copy of the Garrity rules and regulations"; and a copy of notes taken by Sgt. Eric Collins "that were made when he was a witness when [Mrs. Meats] filed with Lt. Earl a request for religious accommodationAppeal partially granted
88https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=01-0901-09William Jacob vs. American Fork CityRecords pertaining to commissions paid to Tom Hunter and/or Hunter & Associates by third parties and any documentation of services rendered by Mr. Hunter and/or his firm "to every City department on every Wednesday of each week"Appeal denied
89https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=01-1001-10Packaging Corp. of America vs. Utah Labor Commissioncopy of an OSHA complaint file, number 201550514Appeal granted
90https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=01-1101-11William Jacob vs. American Fork CityRecords pertaining to American Fork City's August 1997 request for proposals (RFP) for employee benefit consulting servicesAppeal granted
91https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=02-0102-01Brent Poll vs. South Weber CityMinutes from a closed meetingAppeal denied
92https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=02-0202-02Robert Rice vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsPrison policies and procedures concerning inmate and visitor management and security, including searches and involuntary medical treatmentAppeal denied
93https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=02-0302-03Michael T. McCoy vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeCopies of the contract or contracts between the State of Utah and/or the Utah Attorney General's Office and the law firm of Ray, Quinney & Nebeker in which the law firm agrees to provide legal representation in the cases styled Utah Education Association et al, vs. Michael Leavitt, et alAppeal granted
94https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=02-0402-04Harold Sersland vs. Dept. of Natural Resources-Div. of Wildlife ResourcesData on "guzzler" locations in the Dugway and Thomas mountain ranges of Tooele and Juab countiesAppeal denied
95https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=02-0502-05Disability Law Center vs. Utah Transit AuthorityRecords concerning wheelchairs and scooters using respondent's paratransit serviceAppeal granted
96https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=02-0602-06Mr. Pooper Scooper, Inc. vs. Murray and Sandy CityHome addresses of licensed dog ownersAppeal denied
97https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=02-0702-07Brent Poll vs. South Weber CityLegal opinions of South Weber City's attorney concerning a proposal regarding 1375 East and the City's decision regarding that proposalAppeal denied
98https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=02-0802-08Adrian Hickey vs. Dept of CorrectionsPhotographs which were taken of petitioner's tattoos while housed in the prison's Uinta II facilityAppeal denied
99https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=02-0902-09Albert Cramer vs. Murray CityChild witness interview transcripts, police department policies and other documents petitioner believes pertained to his criminal casesAppeal denied
100https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=02-1002-10Mark Powell vs. Lehi CityVisual and/or audio records of petitioner's visit to the Lehi library 23 Aug 02, including interactions with staffAppeal denied
101https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=03-0103-01Darren C. Bluemel vs. Dept. of Public SafetyPetitioner's DNA profile maintained by the Department of Public SafetyAppeal granted
102https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=03-0203-02Douglas D. Jones vs. Dept. of Human Services, Office of Recovery ServicesAll communications between O.R.S. and their legal counsel; all records that show ownership of property, business, stocks, bonds or title to any thing with a monetary value; and all protected and non-protected government information in petitioner's fileAppeal denied
103https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=03-0303-03Kevin Tolton vs. Town of AltaVarious records petitioner maintains are in the Town of Alta's possessionAppeal partially granted
104https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=03-0403-04Inner City Press, Community on the Move & Fair Finance Watch vs. Utah Attorney GeneralRecords related to the recent settlement with Household International, Inc.Appeal denied
105https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=03-0503-05Brent Poll vs. South Weber CityRecords relating to a city council presentation from U.S. Development concerning a potential land transaction involving the city and that companyAppeal granted
106https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=03-0603-06Sean Timothy Hughes vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsAudio tapes made during nine disciplinary hearingsAppeal granted
107https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=03-0703-07Kevin Tolton vs. Town of AltaVarious documents petitioner maintains are, or should be, in the Town of Alta's possessionAppeal partly granted
108https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=03-0803-08Ricardo Rodriguez vs. Utah Board of Pardons and ParoleDocuments used by the Board of Pardons and Parole (the "Board") in petitioner's recent re-determination hearingAppeal denied
109https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=03-0903-09Robin C. Boon vs. Utah Transit AuthorityHandwritten notes of Lorin Simpson and "other documents prepared by Lorin Simpson and Nancy Malecker" concerning appellant's 2002 performance reviewAppeal granted
110https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=03-1003-10Frank Medel, Jr. vs. Utah Dept. of Public SafetyAll written reports generated by the Utah State Crime Lab in the analysis of physical evidence of specific incidentsAppeal denied
111https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=03-1103-11Jeff Iverson vs. West Bountiful CityPayroll information about the city manager.Appeal partly granted
112https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-0104-01Jeremy Beckham vs. University of UtahAll approved protocols for all approved research currently utilizing baboons or macaquesAppeal partly granted
113https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-0204-02Brian K. Stack vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsOffender Management Review Committee results regarding prisoners referred to OMR for communicating with women prisonersAppeal denied
114https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-0304-03William Jacob vs. American Fork CityRecords of any investigation conducted by the mayor or city council concerning the qualifications of any candidate for officeAppeal denied
115https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-0404-04Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance and the Wilderness Society vs. Utah State Attorney GeneralRecords concerning potential applications for recordable disclaimers of interest for Utah roads, specifically R.S. 2477 rights of wayAppeal partially granted
116https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-0504-05Paul Payne vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsEmployee list/personel rosterAppeal denied
117https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-0604-06Victor Orvis vs. Pleasant Grove CityAll lists created by [Pleasant Grove] City personnel involving all businesses or persons who were mailed or otherwise received [Carol Emery's July 19, 2001] letter regarding business license enforcementAppeal partly granted
118https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-0704-07Larry Vernon vs. Coalville CityThe taped recording parts of Coalville City Council Meetings referred to in the available minutes of City Coucil Executive Session meetings.Appeal denied
119https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-0804-08Lisa Olsen vs. Utah Department of Human ServicesQualitative Case Review on Jesse OlsenAppeal denied
120https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-0904-09Jeremy Beckham vs. University of UtahA fee waiver for the fees associated with producing all approved protocols for all research currently utilizing baboons and/or macaques.Appeal denied
121https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-1004-10Steven Onysko vs. University of UtahFinal Grade Report for MG EN 499, Fall Quarter 1995.Appeal denied
122https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-1104-11Haik vs. Town of AltaThe Town of Alta to permit inspection during normal business hours and require the Town of Alta to timely respond to pending records requests.Appeal partly granted
123https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-1204-12LaPlante/Canham (Salt Lake Tribune) vs. Sandy CityThe names of all current Sandy City fire and police employees.Appeal granted
124https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-1304-13Collier Hoffman vs. Division of Occupational and Professional LicensingAny investigations/complaint information regarding Jo-Anne Collier Hoffman.Appeal dismissed
125https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-1404-14Poll vs. South Weber CityAccess to draft minutes of the August 26, 2004 South Weber City Planning Commission meeting.Appeal Denied
126https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-1504-15Haik vs. Town of Alta (noncompliance)Sanctions for the Town's noncompliance with the Order and Decision dated September 21, 2004.Appeal granted
127https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-1604-16LaPlante (Salt Lake Tribune) vs. Salt Lake City Police DepartmentAll initial reports from a 'missing person' case inolving Lori Kay Hacking, filed on or about July 19, 2004" and "all initial reports involving suspect, victim or involved person Mark Douglas Hacking.Appeal Denied
128https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=04-1704-17Steed vs. Duchesne CountyAccess to various documents he believes are in Duchesne County's possession.Appeal granted
129https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=05-0105-01Ostler vs. State of Utah, Departments of Public Safety, Commerce, Human Resource Management, Human Services, Attorney General's Office, Labor Commission, and Salt Lake Community CollegeAccess to various documents referencing his name that he believes are in the custody of the various agencies of the State of Utah.Appeal Denied
130https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=05-0205-02Salt Lake City Corporation vs. Salt Lake Mayor's Records Appeals BoardSalt Lake City Corporation appeals the decision of the Salt Lake City Mayor's Records Appeals Board granting access to certain records requested by Neal K. Ostler.Appeal partly granted
131https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=05-0305-03LaPlante/Canham (Salt Lake Tribune) vs. Sandy CityRecords pertaining to overtime and bonuses paid to Sandy City's police and fire department personnel.Appeal granted
132https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=05-0405-04Schwarz vs. University of UtahAny records on Barbara Schwarz or Schwartz, Mark C. Rathbun, Mark de Rothschild, Scientology, Church of Scientology, L. Ron Hubbard, and Dwight David Eisenhower.Appeal Denied
133https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=05-0505-05Wells vs. Pleasant Grove CityVarious records which relate to a citation received for allegedly electioneering within 150 feet of a polling place.Appeal Denied
134https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=05-0605-06Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance vs. Automated Geographic Reference CenterRecords concerning [certain] roads/routes located in Emery County.Appeal DeniedRuling reversed by Utah Supreme Court case 2008 UT 88https://archives.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/SUWA122308.pdf
135https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=05-0705-07Whitney vs. Department of CorrectionsAccess to grievances that inmates filed against him in November 2004 and the "level 1, level 2, level 3 responses" to the grievance.Appeal Denied
136https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=05-0805-08Schwaar vs. Department of CorrectionsA copy of his diagnostic report.Appeal denied
137https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=05-0905-09Payne vs. Department of CorrectionsA copy of the Uinta 1 Inmate Roster for the date of 8-4-05.Appeal denied
138https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=06-0106-01Tribune vs. Governor's OfficeThe names of companies promised monetary incentives by the State of Utah, as well as e-mail correspondence between the GOED employees, GOED board members and company officials relating to these specific incentive awards.Appeal partly granted
139https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=06-0206-02Williams vs. Board of Pardons and ParoleCertain pages of a Board of Pardons document entitled "Hearing Worksheet" which contains various details about his personal history and sentence being served at the Utah State PrisonAppeal partly granted
140https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=06-0306-03Spectrum vs. Washington CityAll lawyers fees that were and are associated with the Cloud Moving and Storage vs. Washington City lawsuit.Appeal Granted
141https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=06-0406-04Treff vs. Utah Tax CommissionA copy of the 2004 and 2005 state tax returns filed by Mormons for Equality and Social Justice.Appeal Denied
142https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=06-0506-05Salt Lake Tribune vs. Salt Lake Police Dept. Civilian Review BoardPersonnel performance evaluations and disciplinary actionsAppeal Partially Granted
143https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=06-0606-06Monique Crowley vs. Sandy CityRecords regarding personnel matters, and dismissal action against Monique CrowleyAppeal Denied
144https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=06-0706-07Deborah Langdon vs. Utah Dept. of Human ServicesFatality review reportsAppeal Granted
145https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=06-0806-08Joycelyn Straight vs. Lieutenant Governor's OfficeRecords of Utah voter registrations, and a fee waiver for those recordsAppeal Partially Granted
146https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=06-0906-09Bruce Funk vs. Emery CountyRecords of executive sessions held by the Emery County CommissionAppeal Denied
147https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=06-1006-10Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance vs Division of Oil, Gas, and MiningFee waiver for recordsAppeal Denied
148https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=06-1106-11William H. Doutis, Jr. vs. Dept. of CorrectionsRecords associated with his correctional history held by the Dept. of Corrections, plus a waiver of fees.Appeal Denied
149https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=06-1206-12Karl Dee Kay vs. Dept. of CorrectionsPolygraph, "C" notes, and treatment notesAppeal Denied
150https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-0107-01Elizabeth Neff, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Beaver CountyRecords of Beaver County Sheriff's Department, including records and reports regarding Grace S. and Robert Gerald Erno.Appeal partly granted
151https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-0207-02Kathy Dopp vs. Summit CountyRecords of Summit County election summary dataAppeal denied
152https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-0307-03Reginald Williams vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeRecords of "the Martinez report U.S. District Court Case No. 201:CV 798-TC," as well as "any motions, briefs, replies, answers or defendant affidavits filed by the Attorney General regarding Greathouse v. Sibbett or Granquillhome v. the UT BD of Pardons and Paroles."Appeal granted
153https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-0407-04Michael McAinsh vs. Dept. of CorrectionsRecords containing raw data used in the 2005 sex offender treatment and recidivism report.Appeal partly granted
154https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-0507-05Kenneth R Ivory vs. Summit CountyRecords of the Summit County Attorney's Office relating to Brody Taylor, John Moon & Stacy Headrick.Appeal partly granted
155https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-0607-06Marvin Melville vs. Town of AltaRecords of the Town of AltaAppeal granted
156https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-0707-07Tom Corlew vs. Utah State Tax CommissionRecords of an administrative Law Judge's notes of a Tax Commission HearingAppeal denied
157https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-0807-08Mark Haik vs. Town of AltaRecords of the Town of Alta, specifically the tape of the closed meeting held on December 14, 2006Appeal partly granted
158https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-0907-09Katie Patterson vs. University of UtahRecords of the University of Utah, specifically the employee roster, including names, titles and salaries of the employees of the University of Utah Animal Research Center ("ARC")Appeal partly granted
159https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-1007-10Reginald Williams vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeA waiver of the fees assessed by the Utah Attorney General's Office for providing certain records.Appeal denied
160https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-1107-11Steven Onysko vs. Dept. of Human Resource ManagementRecords of the Utah Department of Human Resource Management ("DHRM") specifically the raw candidate interview scores for a State Engineer 4 position.Appeal partly granted
161https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-1207-12Marvin Melville vs. Town of AltaRecords from the Town of Alta regarding the Alta Helena MineAppeal denied
162https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-1307-13Russ Rizzo and the Salt Lake Tribune vs. City of South Salt LakeRecords from the City of South Salt Lake regarding police response times to priority one callsAppeal partly granted
163https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-1407-14Russ Rizzo and the Salt Lake Tribune vs. City of West JordanRecords from the City of West Jordan regarding police response times to priority one callsAppeal partly granted
164https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-1507-15Scott Clark vs. Dept. of Human ServicesDetermining the existence of foster care and child protection service files relating to abuse or maltreatment of Chris (Zachary) prior to his placement for adoption by Mr. And Mrs. Clark, including medical recordsAppeal dismissed
165https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=07-1607-16Margaret Dayton vs. Utah State Office of EducationGrant application submitted by Brigham Young University in 2006Appeal granted
166https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-0108-01Steven J. Onysko vs. Dept. of Environmental QualityAll documents related to petitioner's reassignment from the Division of Drinking Water Engineering Section ManagerAppeal granted
167https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-0208-02Nate Carlisle & the Salt Lake Tribune vs. Dept. of CorrectionsCopies of the reviews conducted upon county jails in 2007, and any corrective action takenAppeal denied
168https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-0308-03Russell Shane Johnson vs. South Jordan CityAll records of discipline against South Jordan police officers over the past three yearsAppeal partly granted
169https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-0408-04Andalex Resources, Inc; Genwal Resources, Inc; and UtahAmerican Energy, Inc; vs.Intermountain Power AgencyOverturn Intermountain Power Agency's decision to release redacted records to the Salt Lake TribuneAppeal denied
170https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-0508-05First American Core Logic vs. Uintah CountyCounty tax and assessment rolls, and all real property characteristicsAppeal partly granted
171https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-0608-06Beth Campbell vs. Salt Lake City CorpRequests a complete and accurate response to her GRAMA request, and access to records the responded claims do not existAppeal denied
172https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-0708-07Thomas D. Boyle vs. Wasatch CountyUnedited surveillance videotapes from video cameras located in the County Clerk's officeAppeal denied
173https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-0808-08Tara Clanton vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsRecords or investigations of the Department of Corrections regarding Nathan Hansen and Ivan HodgesAppeal partly granted
174https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-0908-09Mark Haik vs. Town of AltaRecords contained in a binder issued to and used by members of the Planning and Zoning Commission in an open meeting held on February 29, 2008Appeal granted
175https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-1008-10Steven Maese vs. Murray CityRecords of sustained discipline of Murray City Police Officers, for which all time periods for administrative appeal have expired, for the last 5 yearsAppeal partly granted
176https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-1108-11Ken Murray vs. Dept. of CorrectionsRecords pertaining to Utah’s methods and procedures for capital punishmentAppeal partly granted
177https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-1208-12Steven Oberbeck vs. Utah Public Service CommissionNames and addresses of persons who filed formal complaints with the PSC against Questar Gas in March, 2008, regarding malfunctioning transpondersAppeal granted
178https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-1308-13Dan Fazzini vs. Utah Transit AuthorityRecords of the Utah Transit Authority (“UTA”) pertaining to all complaints with regard to cyclists and UTA in the year 2007Appeal partly granted
179https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-1408-14Stacy Ray Peterson vs. Board of Pardons and ParoleE-mail records of the members of the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole pertaining to a Parole Board hearing held regarding Utah State Prison InmateAppeal denied
180https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-1508-15Marian Olson vs. Office of the Attorney GeneralRecords pertaining to a review by the Attorney General’s Office of decisions made by the Cache County Attorney’s Office regarding a protective orderAppeal denied
181https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-1608-16Jim Garside vs. Salt Lake CityA joint defense agreement between Salt Lake City Corporation and Big Cottonwood Lower Canal CompanyAppeal denied
182https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-1708-17Steve Onysko vs. Dept. of Environmental QualityRecords of the Department of Environmental Quality, pertaining to petitioner's duties and performance during his employment with the Utah Division of Drinking Water.Appeal denied
183https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-1808-18Investigative Research vs. Utah Dept. of TransportationRecords concerning: (1) Traffic Volume Studies, Engineering Studies, Speed Studies, Accident Studies, Barricade Studies, Sign Studies, or other reengineering studies conducted for U.S. 163, mile post 28 to mile post 30; (2) the historical installation, removal and/or replacement of traffic signage on U.S. 163; and (3) changes in roadside devices, such as barricades, barrier walls, wood guide posts or roadside markers on U.S. 163.Appead granted
184https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-1908-19Utah Federal Defender Office vs. Mark Shurtleff, Utah Attorney GeneralN/AOrder of continuance
185https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=08-2008-20Utah Federal Defender Office vs. Mark Shurtleff, Utah Attorney GeneralRecords of communications between the Utah Division of Finance and Criminal Appeals Division of the Utah Attorney General’s OfficeAppeal granted
186https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-0109-01Hilarie Orman, Spanish Fork News vs. Utah CountyInitial contact reports from the Utah County Sheriff's Office concerning a reported trespass on September 21, 2008 and a motorcycle accident on April 29, 2008Appeal granted
187https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-0209-02Tina Wollenberger vs. Summit CountyInterviews of her minor son with the Summit County Sheriff’s OfficeOrder of continuance and submission of costs
188https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-0309-03Pamela Manson, Salt Lake Tribune vs. University of UtahRecords pertaining to a settlement agreement between the University and Lisa A. Speckman.Appeal partly granted
189https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-0409-04Marvin Melville vs. Salt Lake City CorpNotes, drafts or similar materials prepared by Jeff Niermeyer concerning an affidavit dated and executed by Mr. Niermeyer, an employee of Salt Lake City Corporation on May 22, 2008.Appeal denied
190https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-0509-05Nichole Coombs vs. Monticello Charter SchoolRecords regarding an executive/closed meeting of Respondent Monticello Charter School Board, plus invoices and check stubs for legal services.Appeal partially granted
191https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-0609-06Corey Vonberg vs. Dept. of Public SafetyRecords pertaining to an individual from the Utah Highway Patrol Office located in Cedar City, UtahAppeal denied
192https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-0709-07Kevin Anderson vs. Utah Labor CommissionRecords related to the 2007 Crandall Canyon coal mine accident.Appeal denied
193https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-0809-08Anteo T. Reese vs. Utah Board of Pardons and ParoleA written transcript of the April 7, 2009 hearing of the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole (“Board”), free of charge.Appeal denied
194https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-0909-09Eric Peterson (City Weekly) vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeOrder of continuance granted
195https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-1009-10Eric Peterson (City Weekly) vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeSecond order of continuance granted
196https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-1109-11Evan Johnson vs. Salt Lake City Dept. of Public UtilitiesUn-redacted copies of general outsourced legal invoices from the Salt Lake City Department of Public UtilitiesAppeal granted
197https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-1209-12William Justesen vs. Millard CountyNotes, drafts or similar materials prepared by Millard County, Utah, (“County”) concerning records associated with the County’s “step and grade” policy/plan, the “Apple Program,” and the approval or denial of a pay raise/reduction for any County employee or department.Appeal partially granted
198https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-1309-13The Salt Lake Tribune vs. Granite School District, et al.Records of the Respondents, Granite, Jordan and Salt Lake School Districts (“Districts”), specifically dates of birth for certain District employees who may have a criminal conviction.Appeal partially granted
199https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-1409-14Cathy McKitrick (Salt Lake Tribune) vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAll correspondence between Utah Attorney General, Mark Shurtleff and U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder since January 1, 2009. Specifically, the Tribune is seeking access to a letter dated March 23, 2009 from Mr. Shurtleff to Mr. Holder regarding U.S. Attorney Brett TolmanAppeal granted
200https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-1509-15Eric Peterson (City Weekly) vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeInternal documents, memos, or E-mails from Respondent, the Utah Attorney General’s Office (“AG’s Office”) that may have been sent between the AG’s Office and the Utah Division of Consumer Protection regarding “Mentoring of America” and its member companies; and any E-mails, files, or documents from within the AG’s Office regarding Mentoring of AmericaAppeal partially granted
201https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-1609-16Rebecca Haynes vs. Dixie Deer Special Service DistrictA grant/loan application by Respondent, the Dixie Deer Special Service District (“DDSSD”) to the United States Department of Agriculture’s Rural Development officeAppeal denied
202https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-1709-17Pamela Brady (Intermountain Claims, Inc) vs. Dept. of Public Safety, Utah Highway PatrolAn accident report for an auto accident which occurred on May 14, 2009Appeal denied
203https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=09-1809-18Daniel Kneisley vs. Dept. of Public SafetyRecords pertaining to a private investigator, Kim Thomas CollinsAppeal partly granted
204https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-0110-01Mark Haik vs. Town of AltaRecords allegedly held by the Town of Alta.Appeal denied
205https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-0210-02Lori Pritchard/KSL Television vs. Division of Facilities Construction and ManagementDates and times for state employees working at the Heber Wells Building, via scans of their security access cards from September 1, 2008 through March 31, 2009.Appeal denied
206https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-0310-03Lawrence Jackson vs. Utah Dept. of CorrectionsWaiver of fees charged by the Utah Department of Corrections to cover the actual cost of providing Mr. Jackson records he has requested.Appeal granted
207https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-0410-04Paul Richins vs. Davis CountyRecords held by Davis County relating to the assessment of property owned by Mr. Richins in Farmington, Utah.Appeal granted
208https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-0510-05Chris Vanocur/ABC 4 News vs. Utah Dept. of Public SafetyArrest records and dashboard camera video relating to the arrest of Sheldon Killpack on January 15, 2010.Appeal granted
209https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-0610-06Steve Maxfield vs. Office of Lieutenant GovernorWaiver of fees charged by the Office of the Lieutenant Governor to cover the cost of providing Mr. Maxfield the “Statewide Voters Registration List” he requested.Appeal denied
210https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-0710-07Scott Eastmond/KSL TV vs. Carbon CountyPolice report and a surveillance video relating to an alleged assault which took place at Carbon High School.Appeal partially granted
211https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-0810-08Robert Resendes vs. Sevier School DistrictRecords of a household application for free and reduced price school lunch under the federal school lunch programAppeal denied
212https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-0910-09Salt Lake Tribune and Deseret News vs. Utah Dept. of Public SafetyArrest records and dashboard camera video relating to the arrest of Sheldon Killpack on January 15, 2010Appeal granted
213https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-1010-10Eric Peterson, Reporter for the City Weekly, vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeRegarding in-camera review of recordsOrder of Continuance
214https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-1110-11Eric Peterson, Reporter for the City Weekly, vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAll documents including emails and other correspondence, regarding TMI, LLC or TMI Enterprises, Tim Lawson or Jeremy Johnson, separately and/or together, for a period extending from January 1, 2008 through November 12, 2009.Appeal partly granted
215https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-1210-12R. K. Shimabukuro vs. Weber CountyRecords including notes, drafts or similar materials prepared by Respondent, Weber County, Utah, (“Weber County”) supporting the County’s “Board of Equalization Decision” associated with the tax assessment of real property owned by Mr. Shimabukuro.Appeal granted
216https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-1310-13Laura Hancock, Reporter for the Deseret News vs. Utah Transit AuthorityTo appeal a determination by Respondent, the Utah Transit Authority (“UTA”), that fifty-cents per-page for copies of records is a “reasonable fee.”Appeal denied
217https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-1410-14Jeff Salt, Jordan River Restoration Network, vs. Salt Lake City CorporationRecords regarding the proposed regional sports complex to be located adjacent to the Jordan River. Respondent, Salt Lake City Corporation (“SLC”); also, a cross-appeal to the decision of the Salt Lake Appeals Board granting a “fee waiver” to JRRN associated with its records request to SLC.Appeal partly grantedSee also court case.https://archives.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/SLC-vs-JRRN.pdf
218https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-1510-15Nasrulla Khan vs. Utah Dept. of Public SafetyAll documentation regarding petitioner's 2002 complaints to the Department of Public Safety about alleged terrorist acts being committed against himAppeal denied
219https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-1610-16Shawn and Barbara Lewis vs. Dept. of Human ServicesAll documentation pertaining to Mr. Lewis’ daughter and Ms. Lewis’ granddaughter, including her DCFS, adoption, medical, and juvenile court recordsAppeal denied
220https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-1710-17Blake A. Nakamura vs. Salt Lake City Corp.Records of all written and electronic communication between the City, Salt Lake County, and/or the Salt Lake Valley Health Department regarding the Rail Event Center.Appeal denied
221https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-1810-18Tab L. Uno vs. Salt Lake City School DistrictList of school community chairs of the schools in the school district, including their names, addresses, and telephone numbers, and e-mail addresses, if available, and the schools they represent.Appeal denied
222https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-1910-19Linda Houskeeper vs. Utah County Attorney General's OfficeAll records, documents, physical evidence, video recordings, notes, legal brief, etc. on 4th District Court, Utah County criminal case #991405159.Order of Continuance
223https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-2010-20Linda Houskeeper vs. Utah County Attorney General's OfficeAll records, documents, physical evidence, video recordings, notes, legal brief, etc. on 4th District Court, Utah County criminal case #991405159.Appeal partly granted
224https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-2110-21Heirs of Renee Fleckenstein vs. Sandy CityOrder of Continuance
225https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-2210-22Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Board of Pardons and ParoleCopy of letter written in 1988 by Inmate, Mark Hofmann and submitted to Respondent, the Utah Board of Pardons and ParoleAppeal granted
226https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=10-2310-23Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Department of TransportationCopies of correspondence, meeting minutes or other records since Aug 1, 2009 involving UDOT employees and the following parties: Wadsworth Bros. Construction, R.L. Wadsworth Construction, or Guy Wadsworth.Appeal denied
227https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-0111-01Linda Houskeeper vs. Utah County Attorney General's OfficeAll records, documents, physical evidence, video recordings, notes, legal brief, etc. on 4th District Court, Utah County criminal case #991405159.Appeal denied
228https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-0211-02Jesse Fruhwirth vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsRecords documenting the housing history for ten living and two deceased inmates who are or were incarcerated in the Utah prison systemAppeal partly granted
229https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-0311-03Nate Carlisle, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Salt Lake City Police DepartmentAll materials, including video of the confrontation and shooting, police reports, narrative reports, and photographs related to an August 27, 2010 shooting of Brandon Barrett.Appeal granted
230https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-0411-04Chadwick M. Smith vs. Utah State Tax CommissionInvestigation files held by Respondent, the Utah State Tax Commission.Appeal partly granted
231https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-0511-05Bruce Fordham vs. Utah Department of Human ResourcesRecords associated with a case involving Petitioner and a resident in the Utah State Development Center.Appeal denied
232https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-0611-06Eric Peterson vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeE-mail and text messages from Respondent, the Utah Attorney General’s Office.Order of continuance
233https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-0711-07Salt Lake Tribune vs. Southern Utah UniversityRecords pertaining to Roger Reid’s employment as the men’s basketball coach of SUU.Appeal denied
234https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-0811-08Steven Onysko vs. Utah State Tax CommissionRecords pertaining to Petitioner's 2007-2009 State of Utah income tax returns.Appeal partly granted
235https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-0911-09Ray Wheeler vs. Salt Lake CityRequest for a fee waiver for records regarding the proposed regional sports complex to be located adjacent to the Jordan River.Appeal granted
236https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-1011-10Eric Peterson vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeE-mail and text messages from Respondent, the Utah Attorney General’s Office.Appeal partly granted
237https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-1111-11Reginald Williams vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsDocuments regarding the inmate trust fund account from Respondent, the Utah Department of Corrections.Appeal denied
238https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-1211-12Dan Schroeder vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeDocuments regarding a criminal investigation of “Envision Ogden” by the Utah Attorney General’s Office (AG’s Office) that commenced in March 2009 and concluded in March 2011.Appeal partly grantedSee also District Court and Utah Supreme Court rulings.https://archives.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/DistrictCourt-regarding-srcappeal-2011-12.pdf and https://archives.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/UtahSupremeCourt-2015UT77-regarding-srcappeal-2011-12.pdf
239https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-1311013Jeffrey Gallup vs. Board of Pardons and Parole(1) Any emails generated by and between the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole and Melanie Serassio regarding Petitioner, (2) Any emails sent or received by and between the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole and Michelle M. Young regarding Petitioner, and (3) Any and all correspondence, letters, reports, recommendations, and any and all information in the Board of Pardon’s and Parole’s possession regarding Petitioner.Appeal denied
240https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-1411-14Judy Fahys, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Department of Community and CultureRecords pertaining to staff changes and/or restructuring in the archaeology section of DCC.Appeal granted
241https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=11-1511-15Steven OnyskoA fee waiver to receive documents requested and pursuant to the Declaration and Order 11-08 dated June 20, 2011Appeal partly granted
242https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-0112-01Judy Fahys, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Department of Community and CultureOrder of continuance
243https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-0212-02William Burgess, Appignani Humanist Legal Center vs. Utah Transit AuthorityAppeal dismissed
244https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-0312-03Carl Dinger vs. Cottonwood Heights CityRecords pertaining to a report from an investigation performed by the Cottonwood Heights Police Department into Mr. Dinger’s allegations against UTA’s Police Department.Appeal partly granted
245https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-0412-04Wesley Thompson vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsRecords pertaining to petitioner's Correctional Adjustment checklist and life history documents used by correctional officers to determine with which other inmates Mr. Thompson can be housed.Appeal denied
246https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-0512-05Judy Fahys, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Department of Community and CultureRecords pertaining to staff changes and/or restructuring in the archaeology section of DCC.Appeal partly granted
247https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-0612-06Gordon Thomas vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyRecords associated with petitioner's criminal history.Appeal denied
248https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-0712-07Andrew Morse of Snow Christensen & Martineau vs. Canyons School DistrictRecords pertaining to the grievance proceedings of a former Canyons employee against Canyons School District.Appeal denied
249https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-0812-08Alma T. Wilson vs. Utah Department of Human Services, Office of Administrative HearingsRecords regarding the Office of Administrative Hearings.Appeal partly granted
250https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-0912-09Kurt Danysh vs. Unified Police DepartmentRecords related to the police investigation of the murder of Susan Gall.Appeal partly granted
251https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-1012-10Alan Grant vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsSecurity/surveillance video footage from December 26, 2009Appeal denied
252https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-1112-11Ken Cromar vs. City of Cedar HillsE-mails to and/or from certain members of the City of Cedar Hills governing bodyAppeal granted
253https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-1212-12Mark Haik vs. Salt Lake City CorporationCompliance with the decision …of the [Salt Lake City] Mayor’s Records Appeals Board or review of the noncompliance by the State Records CommitteeAppeal dismissed
254https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-1312-13W. Andrew McCullough vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyDriver license records related to a vehicle being impounded.Appeal partly granted
255https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-1412-14Gordon Thomas vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyRecords associated with his criminal history.Appeal denied
256https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-1512-15Ross George vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsList of all officers, sergeants, lieutenants, captains, and case workers who were on shift in the Boulder Hickory Unit and the Dogwood Unit operated by the Department for four specific dates.Appeal granted
257https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-1612-16Mark Haik vs. Salt Lake City CorporationSanctions against Salt Lake City Corporation for what he contends was its failure to disclose certain requested records in a timely manner.Appeal dismissedSee also court rulinghttp://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=3368262720344977905&q=20130383&hl=en&as_sdt=4,45
258https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-1712-17Michael Gubarev vs. Utah Department of Workforce ServicesRecords regarding administrative adjudicative decisions from the Department of Workforce Services relating to interpreters/translators working for certain employers/businesses.Appeal granted
259https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-1812-18Christian Probasco, Sanpete Messenger vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyRecords regarding the name of a minor involved in an auto-pedestrian accident occurring on June 5, 2012, near Fountain Green, UtahAppeal granted
260https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-1912-19Ken Cromar vs. City of Cedar HillsFee waiver request for the costs to provide access to emails to and/or from certain members of the City of Cedar Hills governing body; also the imposition of a civil penalty subsequent to Cromar v. Cedar Hills, State Records Committee Case. No. 12-11 (June 26, 2012).Appeal denied
261https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-2012-20Erin Alberty, reporter for the Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyRecords regarding an officer involved shooting that occurred on March 12, 2006Appeal partly granted
262https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-2112-21Bill Oram, reporter for the Salt Lake Tribune vs. Granite School DistrictRecords regarding Granite School District’s investigation of an alleged inappropriate relationship between a teacher/coach and a female student.Appeal partly granted
263https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-2212-22Jeffrey B. Lawrence vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyRecords regarding a Department of Public Safety investigation of his complaint filed against a Utah Highway Patrol trooper on September 17, 2011Appeal deniedOverturned by 3rd District Court rulinghttps://archives.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/179991449-Lawrence-v-Utah-Department-of-Public-Safety.pdf
264https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-2312-23Michael Luesse vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAppealing the denial of a fee waiver by the Utah Department of Corrections for his records requests.Appeal denied
265https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-2412-24Janelle Stecklein/Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Transit AuthorityVerified crime handled by [UTA] in 2011, including incident date, offense description, time of offense and geographic coordinates.Appeal granted
266https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-2512-25Robert Baker vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsA copy of Corrections’ TMF06, Medical Operations Manual.Appeal granted
267https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=12-2612-26Stephen Dark, reporter for City Weekly vs. Utah Department of Human ServicesRecords regarding an audit dated January 13, 2011, the Department of Human Services’ response to the audit, and associated e-mailsAppeal denied
268https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-0113-01Sandra J. Senn vs. Utah Department of Public SafetynullOrder of Continuance
269https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-0213-02Cedar Hills Citizens for Responsible Government vs. City of Cedar HillsCopies of legal invoices for the City of Cedar Hills.Appeal Denied
270https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-0313-03Harshad Desai vs. Utah State Tax CommissionPersonal property audits from Garfield CountyOrder of Dismissal
271https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-0413-04Larry Hartlerode vs. Unified Fire Authority of Greater Salt LakeRecords pertaining to various fire complaints made against his property to the Unified Fire Authority of Greater Salt Lake between October 2011 to November 2012.Appeal Partly Granted
272https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-0513-05Phillip Leishman vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsRecords regarding security clearances granted for another prison inmate.Appeal Denied
273https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-0613-06Eric Peterson vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeOrder of Continuance
274https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-0713-07Reginald Williams vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsPeace Officer Standards and Training (“POST”) records for seven former and current Corrections employees.Appeal Denied
275https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-0813-08Eric Peterson vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeOrder of Continuance
276https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-0913-09Clara Fernanda Ruiz vs. Department of Administrative ServicesRecords from the Utah Department of Administrative Services pursuant to Utah’s Government Records Access and Management Act.Appeal Denied
277https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-1013-10Robert Gehrke, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeCopies of any subpoenas for testimony or documents received by the Attorney General’s office or members of the office from federal investigative agencies since April 1, 2013.Appeal Granted
278https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-1113-11Corey Vonberg vs. Iron County Sherriff's OfficePolicy and procedure the office is required to follow in investigating an alleged child sex offense requiring a Children’s Justice Center interview, pertaining to November 2003.Appeal Denied
279https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-1213-12Colleen Schulte vs. Summit County Attorney's OfficeRecords showing all communications between the Summit County Attorney’s Office and Dean Schulte regarding a pending criminal case.Appeal Denied
280https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-1313-13Eric Peterson vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeE-mails, documents, text messages, and other correspondence between employees in the AG’s Office and specified individuals related to the Whitewater VII development investigationAppeal Partially Granted
281https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-1413-14Morgan Fife vs. City of OremDocuments related to a Request for Proposal prepared by the City of Orem, dated April 18, 2013Appeal DeniedSee also Court Rulinghttps://archives.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/morgan-fife-v-orem-4thDistrict.pdf
282https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-1513-15Roger Bryner vs. City of Cottonwood HeightsAny documents showing fees of police records, specified GRAMA request responses, and policies of redaction of police records.Order of Continuance
283https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-1613-16Mark Shenefelt, Managing Editor for the Standard Examiner vs. Willard CityA police report and any associated documents regarding an incident occurring at a residence in Willard on June 27, 2013Appeal Partially Granted
284https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-1713-17Damon Crist vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAll disciplinary records of a doctor employed by Corrections working in the Medical Unit of the Draper Prison.Appeal Denied
285https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-1813-18Reginald Williams vs. Utah Department of Workforce ServicesFirst and final bank statements for the American Recovery Reinvestment Act and Development Block Grant.Appeal Partially Granted
286https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=13-1913-19Roger Bryner vs. City of Cottonwood HeightsPolice reports and communications regarding GRAMA requests.Appeal Partially Granted
287https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-0114-01William Hill vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsPetitioner's Pre-Sentence Investigation ReportAppeal Denied
288https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-0214-02Lee Davidson, reporter for the Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah State Tax CommissionLetters, emails, memos, records of phone calls or other communication from or to the commission and/or its staff from outside parties regarding development of its policy on whether same-sex couples married in other states could file joint returns in Utah.Appeal Partially Granted
289https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-0314-03Nate Carlisle, reporter for the Salt Lake Tribune vs. Bluffdale CityEmail and other correspondence regarding the National Security Agency (NSA), city agreements to allow the NSA to use water for their facility, and records of daily water usage.Appeal Granted
290https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-0414-04Jessica Phillips vs. West Jordan Police DepartmentAny video and audio recording from patrol vehicle dashboards of officers who responded to the scene of the petitioner’s DUI arrest, plus any video of the room in which the intoxilyzer was administered or other rooms in which the petitioner was held.Appeal Granted
291https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-0514-05Lynn Kenneth Packer vs. Utah Attorney General's Office and the Utah Department of Administrative ServicesVehicle fleet records pertaining to vehicles assigned to employees who are investigators for the Utah Attorney General OfficeAppeal Denied
292https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-0614-06Corey Vonberg vs. Iron County Attorney's OfficeRecords which identify Shawn R. Keith as a confidential informant.Appeal Denied
293https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-0714-07Sam Allen vs. Eagle Mountain CityFee waiver for credit card statements and other records received from Eagle Mountain CityAppeal Partially Granted
294https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-0814-08Jack Jessop vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsRecords of all information sheets from the prescription drug manufacturers that accompanied the prescriptions petitioner was receiving while incarcerated by Corrections.Appeal Denied
295https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-0914-09Justin Crosbie vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAll office and field notes entered by an agent regarding Mr. Crosbie, progress reports, as well as polygraph and PPG results, a copy of a warrant request and a parole violation report to the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole, all government cell phone records, including pictures and e-mails generated by Mr. Crosbie’s parole agent, and all outgoing and incoming e-mails by Mr. Crosbie’s parole agent from 2011 to the present.Appeal Denied
296https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-1014-10Corey Vonberg vs. Iron County Attorney's OfficeRecord identifying the date Respondent disposed of its case file for State v. Keith, Case No. 025501031, Fifth District Court, Iron County, State of Utah.Appeal Denied
297https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-1114-11Cathy Johnson vs. Utah Lieutanant Governor's OfficeNotary log.Appeal Denied
298https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-1214-12Raymond Payne vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsFee waiver to obtain a copy of the Corrections’ Policy FD01 Offender Discipline Procedures.Appeal Denied
299https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-1314-13Dennis J. Garcia vs. Utah Board of PardonsRecords that reflect the vote of the members of the Board of Pardons on a restitution order.Appeal Denied
300https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-1414-14Alex Campbell, reporter with Buzzfeed, Inc. vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsA database of all inmates currently housed in the Utah Department of Corrections, including but not limited to: inmate name, inmate number, date of birth, conviction and/or sentence date, offense(s), and sentence length.” Petitioner also requested a fee waiver.Appeal Partially Granted
301https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-1514-15Harshad Desai vs. Garfield County School DistrictFee waiver or a reduction of fees.Appeal Partially Granted
302https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-1614-16Julie Holbrook vs. South Jordan City CouncilA copy of a letter engaging auditors to review Mulligans Golf and Games, and the draft audit report discussed at the July 1, 2014 Council meeting.Appeal Denied
303https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-1714-17Scott Gollaher vs. Morgan CountyAny subpoenas served on a police detective in two criminal cases where Mr. Gollaher is the Defendant.Appeal Granted
304https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-1814-18Truth in Advertising, Inc. vs. Department of Commerce. Division of Consumer ProtectionRecords regarding any investigations and consumer complaints relating to a Utah Company, "Wake Up Now."Appeal Denied
305https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-1914-19Daniel Rivera, Jr. vs. Department of Human Services, Division of Child and Family ServicesCopies of police reports and records related to a police raid at petitioner's residence on October 28, 2011.Appeal Denied
306https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-2014-20Truth in Advertising Inc. vs. Utah Department of Commerce, Division of Consumer ProtectionCopies of consumer complaints filed concerning certain named companies.Appeal Granted
307https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=14-2114-21Jordanelle Special Services District vs. Office of the Utah State AuditorDocuments and other records, including all communication between the Office if the Utah State Auditor and any other person, that relate to the “Standstill Agreement”.Appeal Denied
308https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-0115-01Harshad P. Desai vs. Garfield CountyRecords relating to the appraisals, the individual appraisers and their credentials to appraise properties.Appeal Denied
309https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-0215-02Harshad P. Desai vs. Utah State Tax CommissionRecords relating to individual property appraisers, licensing and the appraisers' credentials to appraise specific properties.Appeal Denied
310https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-0315-03Paul G. Amann vs. Department of Human Resource ManagementA copy of a complaint filed against the Petitioner by an employee of the Utah Department of Commerce alleging “workplace harassment.” Also, all records used to support the complaint, and all communications: (1) To and from the Utah Division of Securities (“Securities”) employees regarding the complaint; (2) Between Securities and the Utah Attorney General’s Office regarding the complaint; and (3) Between the complainant and DHRM.Appeal Granted
311https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-0415-04Maximino Arriaga vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsItemized copies of medical bills for medical services provided to another inmate whom Mr. Arriaga had been found guilty of assaulting the previous year.Appeal Denied
312https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-0515-05Scott Gollaher vs. Department of Public Safety, Division of Peace Officers Standards and Training (POST)Information pertaining to the possible disciplinary action(s) taken against former Detective William Z. Wetland, Badge No.: 20911, with relation to a conference held in Mesquite, Nevada during the week of September 24, 2012.Appeal Denied
313https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-0615-06Scott Gollaher vs. Utah Attorney General's Office Criminal DivisionRecords received from the Salt Lake Police Department, police, staff or agency relating to petitioner, with specific focus on "all video, photos, records and recordings taken by Detective Suzanne Williams" executed on or about July 13, 2012.Appeal Denied
314https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-0715-07Scott Gollaher vs. Weber County Sheriff's OfficeRecords regarding a search warrant relating to petitioner and executed on or about July 13, 2012.Appeal Granted
315https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-0815-08Scott Gollaher vs. Morgan County Attorney's OfficeAll photos, video, records created by Weber County Sheriff’s Office in relationship to the search warrant executed at a specific address on or about July 13, 2012.Appeal Denied
316https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-0915-09Paul Amann vs. Utah Department of Human Resource ManagementOrder of Continuance
317https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-1015-10Harshad P. Desai vs. Panguitch CityList of vendors in relation to the Panguitch City Balloon Festival as well as minutes from a June 24, 2014, meeting with Cheryl Church, manager of an organization known as Panguitch Main Street Committee.Appeal Denied
318https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-1115-11Thomas Dudley Beck vs. Bluff Water Works Special Service DistrictWater usage data from 2007 through 2014.Appeal Granted
319https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-1215-12Heather Gardner vs. Utah State Office of EducationEmailAppeal Dismissed
320https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-1315-13Richard J. Garcia vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsTransportation records from 7-8-14 to present containing all transportation departures, returns, dates, time, and policy regarding restraints.Appeal Denied
321https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-1415-14Daniel Rivera Jr. vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeSearch warrant, Police Reports, Probable Cause Affidavit, CI Statements, Witness Reports from neighbors etc., Statements of Children if any, any and all DCFS statements, petitions, [and] motions filed related to a police raid at petitioner's residence and related to DCFS case #030116813.Appeal Denied
322https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-1515-15Swen Heimberg vs. Peace Officer Standards and TrainingAll investigative files since 2010 that included an allegation under Utah Code § 53-6-211(1)(d), which is conduct that is a state or federal criminal offence, excluding minor traffic offenses.Appeal Denied
323https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-1615-16Paul Amann vs. Department of Human Resource ManagementComplaint filed against petitioner by an employee of the Utah Department of Commerce alleging workplace harassment.Appeal DeniedOverturned by 3rd District Court Ruling
324https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-1715-17Nate Carlisle, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAll incoming and outgoing correspondence concerning Cameron Noel originating in 2014 or 2015 including, but not limited to, letters, emails, text messages and instant messaging programs, and the letter deputizing Troy Rawlings to consider criminal charges against Cameron Noel and any related instructions to Mr. Rawlings.Appeal Partly Granted
325https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-1815-18Karl Losee vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAll e-mail messages between March 6, 2014, and January 9, 2015, generated by specified Corrections’ employees regarding petitioner.Appeal Denied
326https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-1915-19Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of Corrections, Clinical ServicesRecords allegedly held by respondent.Appeal Denied
327https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-2015-20Kevin Opsahl, The Herald Journal vs. Utah State UniversityAll contracts between Maverik and Utah State University related to the corporate sponsorship and renaming of Romney Stadium.Appeal Granted
328https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-2115-21Jason Behar vs. Department of Human Resource ManagementAll records the State of Utah has with petitioner's name on it.Appeal Partly Granted
329https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-2215-22Gray Smith vs. Cottonwood Heights CityAudio of April 9 Board of Adjustment meeting and copies and records of detailed inquiries and investigations of the City’s determination of alleged improper communications of Giverny appeal.Appeal Denied
330https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-2315-23Jamis Johnson vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsDetailed field notes and emails sent and received by Adult Probation and Parole officers wherein petitioner was the subject matter of the records.Appeal Denied
331https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-2415-24Michael Clára vs. Salt Lake City School DistrictInformation in reference to the deployment of Salt Lake City Police Department personnel at the Salt Lake City Board of Education meetings.Appeal Dismissed
332https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-2515-25Tracy Taylor vs. Wasatch County School DistrictEmails between the board, superintendent, and the business administrator in the last year; improvements to the pool at TIS in the last 7 years, and how much; and total cost of curriculum books, broken down by grades and years, for the entire district from 2000-2007.Appeal Denied
333https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-2615-26Richard Parks vs. Utah Division of Consumer ProtectionA copy of the investigative report on Case #83905, and all notes and recorded phone calls concerning a complaint petitioner had filed with Consumer Protection on November 10, 2014.Appeal Partially Granted
334https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-2715-27Roger Bryner vs. Clearfield CityCopies of radio logs, video and audio from patrol vehicle dashboard cameras, evidence logs, manuals, inventory logs, and database entries from 12:00 AM to 4:00 AM on June 3, 2015.Appeal Denied
335https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-27 (Remand)15-27 (Remand)Roger Bryner vs. Clearfield CityCopies of radio logs, video and audio from patrol vehicle dashboard cameras, evidence logs, manuals, inventory logs, and database entries from 12:00 AM to 4:00 AM on June 3, 2015.Appeal DeniedCourt upheld rulinghttps://archives.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/bryner%20150701062.pdf
336https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-2815-28Paul Amann vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeEmployee records, including any and all communications regarding the hiring of the attorney who replaced Mr. Amann at the AG’s Office as assigned legal counsel to the Utah Division of Securities.Appeal DeniedOverturned by 3rd District Court Ruling
337https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-2915-29Scott Gollaher vs. Morgan County Attorney's OfficeThe record or receipt by the Morgan County Attorney's Office of the 5 colored photos emailed that were sent to Mr. Gollaher on March 29, 2015, in relationship to the search warrant executed at a specific address on or about July 13, 2012. In addition, Mr. Gollaher requested receipt and/or record of the October 11, 2013, Children's Justice Center interview on DVD that was sent to Mr. Gollaher on May 6, 2015, via postal mail by Morgan County Attorney's Office.Appeal Denied
338https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-3015-30Nestor Gallo vs. Provo City Housing Authority1) A staff report or documentation related to the increase of the Executive Director Compensation reviewed and approved by the Provo City Housing Authority Boardmeeting dated Wednesday December 17 2014, plus the audio files.2) Saint Francis Apartment project: Copies of the bid schedule including unit prices, quantity take offs and general contractor's contact information and copies of all the change orders including unit prices3) Ekin Project: a) Copy of the project bid schedule with unit quantity take offs from all the contractors b) Contractors' name and contact information.4) A copy of the section of the PCHA code stating that the location of a net play pen is a violation to some form of code, and copy of the audio files from February 25, 2015 PCHA Board public meeting.Appeal Granted
339https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-3115-31Kurt Bailey vs. Perry City Police DepartmentAll written reports, notes and video for a specific citation that occurred on July 18, 2015Appeal Granted
340https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-3215-32John Rice vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsRecords obtained during petitioner's background investigation, and all records relating to discussions regarding previous employment, including what statements were made, and by whom.Appeal Partially Granted
341https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-3315-33Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of Insurance, Fraud DivisionEmail messages or text messages, sent or received by certain individuals where petitioner was the subject, or relating to certain cases.Appeal Partially Granted
342https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=15-3415-34Robert Gehrke, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeCopies of the file of any closed investigation conducted into San Juan County Commissioner Phil Lyman within the last five years.Appeal Granted
343https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-0116-01Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeRecords from the Attorney General's Office. Appeal was in regard to the delay in delivery.Appeal Denied
344https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-0216-02Jordanelle Special Services District vs. Office of the Utah State AuditorAll documents and other records, including all communications between the Office … and any other person, that relate to the ‘Standstill Agreement.’Additionally, all documents and other records, including all communications, received from any person as part of the Utah State Auditor’s Audit of JSSD.Appeal DeniedSee also court case rulinghttps://archives.utah.govhttps://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src/JSSD-Dismissal-Order.pdf
345https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-0316-03Chad Lambourne vs. Provo City Police DepartmentRecords in regards to a Driving Under the Influence (“DUI”) charge and arrest that occurred on July 6, 2015 for petitioner's client.Appeal DeniedSee also court case ruling and summonshttps://archives.utah.govhttps://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src/Lambourne-v-Provo.pdf and https://archives.utah.govhttps://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src/Lambourne-v-Provo-Summons-Feb-2016.pdf
346https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-0416-04Axlen Marchet vs. Utah Department of Public Safety, Bureau of Forensic ServicesDNA test results from a Sexual Assault Evidence Kit (“SEAK”) that was collected in 2003.Appeal Denied
347https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-0516-05Annie Knox, Reporter for the Salt Lake Tribune vs. University of UtahStudent disciplinary cases of violent or sexual crime from 2005 to 2015 that reached a final disposition wherein the student was found guilty.Appeal Denied
348https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-0616-06Michael Clára vs. Salt Lake City School DistrictRecords regarding repairs made to buses that were the subject of a recall, documents relating to the District’s relationship with Columbus Community Center, records pertaining to the District’s communications with the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights, records relating to certain statements made by the District Superintendent in a video interview with the Salt Lake Tribune, and records relating to the District’s RFP JB1541-LS for Professional Legal Services.Appeal Denied
349https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-0716-07Reginald Williams vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeEmployee Service History for eleven individuals.Appeal Partially Granted
350https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-0816-08Helen Redd, for and in behalf of Marc Jensen vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAny and all documents that would support representations of the Office of the Attorney General at the August 23rd 2011 hearing, Jan 30, 2012 letter to the Board of Pardons and Parole and on any other occasion where the AG office made statements that Marc Jensen paid no restitution in Case no. 051905391, (filed 3d Dist Utah).Appeal Granted
351https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-0916-09Edgar Frye vs. Utah Department of Human Services, Division of Aging and Adult ServicesAll records of interviews, phone calls, etc, in the abuse case of petitioner's sister, of St. George, Utah.Appeal Denied
352https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-1016-10Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAny, and all, emailed sent and received by a specific individual that mentioned Mr. Sullivan’s name, or specific case numbers within the subject and/or body of the messages between Jan. 1, 2012 to present.Order of Continuance
353https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-1116-11Roger Bryner vs. Clearfield CityMeeting minutes or any other documents whatsoever showing the Mayor and/or City Counsel, either individually, separately, or through delegation, appointing either permanent or temporary Justice court Judges.Appeal Partly Granted
354https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-1216-12Utah Rivers Council vs. Washington County Water Conservancy DistrictRecords regarding the repayment plan presented by Applied Analysis on November 21, 2013, for the Lake Powell Pipeline Project.Order of Continuance
355https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-1316-13Bryan Thatcher vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyAll written reports, notes, recordings and/or videos of interviews and/or statements, and any other records held by DHRM regarding petitioner. This includes records, documents, notes, and statements from all parties with regard to any and all investigations conducted by internal affairs or professional standards of, or related to petitioner.Order of Continuance
356https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-1416-14Nate Carlisle, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAll documents related to any criminal investigations of Beaver County Sheriff Cameron Noel conducted in 2014 or 2015, including, but not necessarily limited to, police reports, witness statements, forensic reports, search warrant applications and returns, subpoenas and similar documents you may have received from other law enforcement agencies.Order of Continuance
357https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-1516-15Cody Black vs. Lehi City Police DepartmentHiring/promoting methods and results/score for each applicant for each hiring/promotion event in the date range 1/01/15-11/30/15 for the Lehi Police Department Positions: deputy chief, lieutenants, sergeants, corporals, patrol officers.Appeal Partially Granted
358https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-1616-16Roger Bryner vs. Utah Department of HealthPetitioner's medical records from the Utah Department of Health, specifically un-redacted electronic copies, not printouts, and raw files including any file structure for the files, in a .zip file or on a DVD or CD or flash file system.Appeal Denied
359https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-1716-17Edgardo Mata vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsPetitioner's entire STG [security threat group] file, including the validation matrix and all information listed in FD 29-03.02.Appeal DeniedSee also court case rulinghttps://archives.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/mata-v-udc%20160903298.pdf
360https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-1816-18Bryan Thatcher vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyAll written reports, notes, recordings and/or videos of interviews and/or statements, and any other records held by DHRM regarding petitioner. This includes records, documents, notes, and statements from all parties with regard to any and all investigations conducted by internal affairs or professional standards of, or related to petitioner.Appeal Partially Granted
361https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-1916-19Utah Rivers Council vs. Washington County Water Conservancy DistrictRecords regarding the repayment plan presented by Applied Analysis on November 21, 2013, for the Lake Powell Pipeline Project.Appeal Granted
362https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-2016-20Utah Legal Clinic vs. Salt Lake City CorporationAny and all emails sent or received by certain individuals since July 1, 2013, referencing Trenton Mellen and/or specific court case numbers.Order of Continuance
363https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-2116-21Nate Carlisle, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAll documents related to any criminal investigations of Beaver County Sheriff Cameron Noel conducted in 2014 or 2015, including, but not necessarily limited to, police reports, witness statements, forensic reports, search warrant applications and returns, subpoenas and similar documents you may have received from other law enforcement agencies.Appeal Partially Granted
364https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-2216-22Patrick Sullivan vs. University of Utah, Medical CenterOrder of Continuance
365https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-2316-23Utah Legal Clinic vs. Salt Lake City CorporationAny and all emails sent or received by certain individuals since July 1, 2013, referencing Trenton Mellen and/or specific court case numbers.Appeal DeniedSee also court case rulinghttps://archives.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/utahlegalclinic-v-slc.pdf
366https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-2416-24Mark Allen vs. Utah County CommissionInformation concerning an end-of-year employee party held December 2015, including names of invitees, attendees, and emails that were sent.Appeal Granted
367https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-2516-25Daniel Ortiz vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsIncident Reports, including contacts, Narratives and Supplemental on petitioner's Record File, and on O-Track.Appeal Denied
368https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-2616-26Roger Bryner vs. Utah Department of HealthCopies of the results of all blood alcohol tests performed in 2015 from the Utah Department of Health.Appeal Partially Granted
369https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-2716-27Roger Bryner vs. Utah Department of Technology Services1. All design or specification documents for the Department of Health relational databases which store blood alcohol levels obtained from GC testing, any billing documents between departments, and any other records which would tend to specify the type of database used to query capabilities on that database.2. The electronic records, including SQL query and SQL text used to conduct the query, from the relational database of the results of all blood alcohol tests performed in 2015, not including names of persons. 3. The electronic records, including SQL query, from the relational database of the results of all blood alcohol tests performed in 2016 for petitioner.Appeal Denied
370https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-2816-28Patrick Sullivan vs. University of Utah Medical CenterEmails sent and received by various health providers where Mr. Sullivan was the subject; and various medical records (consultation reports, x-ray reports, office visit reports, and EMG/nerve conduction study reports)Appeal Denied
371https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-2916-29Kevin Berry vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsPsychological evaluation, all medication prescribed, housing units staff comments, clinical evaluations, therapist notes [and] comments and communicational comments from the Attorney General's Office.Appeal Denied
372https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-3016-30Reginald Williams vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAll emails to or from UDC to or from the U.S. Attorney or any other person regarding Mr. William's 2-25-16 and 2-26-16 attorney visits.Appeal Denied
373https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-3116-31Michael Clara vs. Utah Transit AuthorityOrder of Continuance
374https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-3216-32Harshad P. Desai vs. Panguitch CityEducation, experience, and résumés for the Mayor and Council Members, as well as for members of the Planning and Zoning Committee and the Panguitch City office staff. Also, a record detailing the total population within a thirty mile radius of Panguitch City.Appeal Denied
375https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-3316-33Michael Clara vs. Utah Transit AuthorityCorrespondence between specified UTA employees pertaining to petitioner, his job title, and/or associated responsibilities. Additionally, records concerning bus stop improvements and references to a bond election.Appeal Partly Granted
376https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-3416-34Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAll emails sent and received by various Corrections employees where petitioner is the subject, and to provide those records on a CD.Appeal Denied
377https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-3516-35Marian Seamons vs. Ticaboo Utility Improvement DistrictItemized billing statements and other records relating to the billing that occurred on lots in Ticaboo, Utah, that petitioner owns.Appeal Denied
378https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-3616-36Jessica Miller on behalf of the Salt Lake Tribune vs. Provo City Police Department and Orem City Police DepartmentCopies of Spillman Case Access Logs for any sexual-related criminal investigation that was accessed by an employee of Brigham Young University, including its police department, from January 2010 to present.Appeal Partly Granted
379https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-3716-37Helen H. Redd, on behalf of Marc Jensen vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeDispute about claim of extraordinary circumstances related to previous records requests.Appeal Denied
380https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-3816-38Roger Bryner vs. Clearfield CityOrder of Continuance
381https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-3916-39Roger Bryner vs. Clearfield CityOrder of Continuance
382https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-4016-40James Duran vs. Utah Department of Human ServicesOrder of Continuance
383https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-4116-41Alex Stuckey, Salt Lake Tribune, vs. Cedar City Police DepartmentAny police reports or investigation records that mentioned a specified individual from 2010 to present.Appeal Granted
384https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-4216-42Alex Stuckey, Salt Lake Tribune, vs. Utah State UniversityAny and all correspondence mentioning Torrey Green from 2009 to present between specifically named individuals.Appeal Denied
385https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-4316-43Tracy Taylor vs. Wasatch County School DistrictAll applications filed with the district for the superintendent’s position awarded June-July 2016: the top four candidates of those applicants, all names of people assigned to the citizen’s committee to review applications for the supervisor’s position, school board’s evaluation process and documents, the process followed for selection- job description of selection committee, who was interviewed, second interview, and who visited the school district.Appeal Partly Granted
386https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-4416-44Roger Bryner vs. Clearfield CityRecords from and about a certain specific facsimile/printer machine used by the Clearfield City Police Department, including purchase receipts, the user manual and service records for the machine; all emails from anyone or to anyone or between people at Clearfield City involving Petitioner covering the time period from 7-10-15 to June 9, 2016; configuration settings of a webpage mentioned in the user manual of a certain printer of the Respondent; and activity log related to a specific printer/facsimile machine.Appeal Denied
387https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-4516-45James Duran vs. Utah Department of Human ServicesRecords of the Millcreek Youth Center in Ogden, Utah.Appeal Denied
388https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-4616-46Paul Wach vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsA copy of “Cautions” within Corrections’ offender database, where Corrections personnel can enter specific “cautions” about inmates housed by Corrections, assisting Corrections Officers in their day-to-day housing, and management of inmates.Appeal Denied
389https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-4716-47Siprut PC vs. Utah State Tax CommissionDocuments involving Intuit, Inc. (“Intuit”), Intuit’s TurboTax Tax Preparation Software (“TurboTax”), and Santa Barbara Tax Products Group, LLC (“SBTPG”) “related to cybersecurity, fraudulent or suspicious tax returns filed” with the Commission.Appeal Denied
390https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-4816-48Lori Williams vs. Pleasant Grove CityRecords related to the annual Strawberry Days festival held annually in Pleasant Grove City.Appeal Granted
391https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-4916-49Nate Carlisle on behalf of the Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah County Sheriff's OfficeAny records of discipline of a police officer that would disclose information relating to a formal charge or disciplinary action against the employee that were sustained; and all records relating to an internal or administrative investigation of the police officer related to allegations of witness tampering, retaliation against a witness, or obstruction of justice.Appeal Granted
392https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-5016-50Eric Peterson vs. Utah Department of HealthAll records that “may contain information relating to deaths caused in whole or in part by prescription overdoses of any kind…” for research purposes.Appeal Denied
393https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=16-5116-51David Larsen vs. Heber City Police DepartmentDepartment personnel records concerning a named police officer.Appeal Partly Granted
394https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-0117-01Alex Stuckey, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah State UniversityAny written findings or reports from an inquiry made by USU President Stan Albrecht regarding recent allegations of sexual assaults in the campus community.Order of Continuance
395https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-0217-02American Civil Liberties Union vs. Salt Lake County District Attorney and the Salt Lake City Police DepartmentCopies of body camera footage and other video footage of a shooting incident which occurred February 27, 2016 involving Abdi Mohamed and police officers with the Salt Lake City Police Department, including but not limited to dash-cam and/or surveillance video.Appeal Granted
396https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-0317-03Earl Al Kalashnikov vs. Salt Lake City CorporationPolice records related to the shooting incident which occurred February 27, 2016 involving Abdi Mohamed and police officers with the Salt Lake City Police Department.Appeal Granted
397https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-0417-04Alex Stuckey, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah State UniversityAll records used to aid in any oral presentation of the inquiry into sexual assaults on campus, its findings and recommendations; all records that resulted in the recommendation and inquiry summary released by USU on August 24, 2016; and any and all video or audio recordings of the oral presentation of the inquiry, its findings and recommendations.Appeal Partly Granted
398https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-0517-05Karl Davis, Shore Lodge Estates HOA vs. Garden CityRecords showing: (1) The amount spent on litigation against Shore Lodge Estates; (2) The source of the funding for the litigation; (3) The projected cost of an eminent domain action against Shore Lodge Estates, and (4) The source of funds for the cost of an eminent domain action.Appeal Partly Granted
399https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-0617-06Paul Amann vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeA variety of specific records, including a complaint filed by AG’s Office employee against Mr. Amann and other named individuals, card key access logs, and a list of every person who had access to a specified Utah AG’s Office employee and/or had knowledge about the employee’s attendance at a “Forensics in Court” program.Appeal Partly Granted
400https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-0717-07Mark Shenefelt, Standard Examiner vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeCopies of audio and video surveillance records for alleged offenses occurring in October and November 2016 involving three named individuals.Appeal Denied
401https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-0817-08Terry Mitchell vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAny and all communications related to petitioner's report of a “child sexual abuse…regarding Chief Justice Judge Richard Roberts.” Ms. Mitchell also requested “all documentation, communication, emails, minutes, phone calls, meetings, correspondence of any kind, on and off record” regarding herself and Judge Roberts.Appeal Denied
402https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-0917-09Jennifer Baptista vs. Pleasant Grove CityAll drafts/notes of City Council Meeting Minutes taken by City Recorder during the meetings for the 2016 year.Appeal Denied
403https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-1017-10Reginald Williams vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsList or page one of all audits performed by Corrections’ internal audit bureau from 2007 to present.Appeal Denied
404https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-1117-11Britt Miller vs. Utah Transit AuthorityAll materials and information provided by the Labor Relations Institute (LRI).Appeal Granted
405https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-1217-12Libertas Institute vs. Utah State Tax CommissionAn agreement between the Commission and the online retailer Amazon regarding Amazon’s collection and remittance of sales tax for Utah consumers.Appeal Granted
406https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-1317-13Utah Rivers Council vs. Utah Division of Water ResourcesAll 2015 water use data submitted to the Division by public water suppliers in Utah.Appeal Granted
407https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-1417-14Robert Baker vs. Board of Pardons and ParoleCopies of 200+ case files supplied by PEW Research Foundation, and copies of Correlation Analysis.Appeal Denied
408https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-1517-15Andrew Becker vs. Washington County Sheriff's OfficePolice reports associated with an incident involving Mr. Becker and the Office occurring on December 30, 2016, and any audio and video recordings from any officer involved in the incident.Appeal Partially Granted
409https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-1617-16Edward Berkovich vs. Millard County Attorney's OfficeNotes or minutes taken at a meeting held on October 21, 2015 by the Utah Prosecution Council (“UPC”).Appeal Partially Granted
410https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-1717-17Paul Amann vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeA voluminous quantity of records held by the Attorney General's Office.Appeal Denied
411https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-1817-18George Chapman vs. Salt Lake City CorporationClosed Executive Session Meeting Minutes of the Salt Lake City Council & RDA meetings that discussed homeless sites.Appeal Denied
412https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-1917-19Steven J. Onysko vs. Jordanelle Special Service DistrictDocumentation, including but not limited to Phone Company billing records, of JSSD outgoing and incoming telephone calls for all telephones and extensions at any JSSD offices, treatment facilities, or other JSSD-associated property from August 1, 2015 to October 16, 2016.Appeal Granted
413https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-2017-20Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsPetitioner requested a fee waiver for the records claiming that release of the records primarily benefits the public rather than a person. Also requested the names of individuals involved in a decision made by Corrections regarding himself.Appeal Partially Granted
414https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-2117-21Paul Amann vs. Utah Department of Human Resource ManagementRecords allegedly held by Respondent.Order of Continuance
415https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-2217-22Edgardo Mata vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsA copy of Corrections’ “O-Track entry” that provides a description of tattoos related to Mr. Mata.Appeal Granted
416https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-2317-23Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsDetailed receipts, invoices, purchase orders, and work orders for new security cameras installed at the Utah State Prison located in Draper, Utah.Appeal Denied
417https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-2417-24Randy M. Andrus vs. Unified Police DepartmentRecords held by Respondent.Order of Continuance
418https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-2517-25Lance Rolph vs. Utah Department of Human Services, Office of Recovery ServicesAny records used by the Office of Recovery Services against petitioner in prior court proceedings.Appeal Denied
419https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-2617-26Anna Burleson, Standard-Examiner vs. Box Elder School DistrictAll applications and accompanying documents for the position of District superintendent in 2017, including letters of reference, qualifications, resumes, cover letters and letters of intent.Appeal Partially Granted
420https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-2717-27Paul G. Amann vs. Department of Human Resource ManagementRecords allegedly held by Respondent.Appeal Partially Granted
421https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-2817-28Matthew Winters vs. West Jordan City Police DepartmentAll video and audio – car camera, body camera and middle school DVD surveillance.Appeal Partially GrantedSee also summonshttps://archives.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/winters%20170906014.pdf
422https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-2917-29Richard Norman Stein vs. Ogden City Police DepartmentAll records pertaining to a case with the Ogden City Police Department.Appeal Dismissed
423https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-3017-30David Larsen vs. Heber City Police DepartmentAll Drug Recognition Expert (DRE) road and field training documents and policies, including any policy changes and who made those changes, for the Heber City Police Department, from 2015 to present.Appeal Denied
424https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-3117-31Kelly James on behalf of Proletariat-Watch vs. Kane County Hospital Special Service DistrictThe Kane County Hospital Chief Executive Officer’s (CEO) salary from 2014 to 2016.Appeal Granted
425https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-3217-32Harshad P. Desai vs. Garfield CountyFee waiver for records requests totalling $15.00.Appeal Denied
426https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-3317-33Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsInvoice showing all calls made, cost of each call, and all deposits made to petitioner's CenturyLink/IC Solutions phone account.Appeal Denied
427https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-3417-34Lee Davidson, Salt Lake Tribune, vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeA copy of the legal opinion requested by legislative leaders about the special election process” to fill the congressional seat held by Representative Jason ChaffetzAppeal Granted
428https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-3517-35Luke Ramseth, Salt Lake Tribune, vs. Murray City Police DepartmentPolice reports and any related investigative documents involving Adam Lim.Appeal Partially Granted
429https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-3617-36Steven Onysko vs. Utah Department of Human Resource ManagementMetadata from certain employees regarding a document purportedly authored by a specific person.Appeal Denied
430https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-3717-37Molly Marcello, The Times-Independent vs. Moab City Police DepartmentAny formal complaints filed with the Moab City Police Department or Moab City regarding a former Moab police officer during his tenure with the department.Appeal Granted
431https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-3817-38Lance Rolph vs. Department of Human Services, Office of Recovery ServicesOffice of Recovery Services Information System’s Guide, and a copy of any and all of ORS’s policies having to do with case records & release of case records, what type of records ORS keeps in case files, evidence, etc.Appeal Denied
432https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-3917-39Wanda Amann vs. Utah Executive Branch Ethics CommissionInformation relating to the hiring of a specific person within the Utah Executive Branch Ethics Commission.Order of Continuance
433https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-4017-40Steven Onysko vs. Utah Department of Human Resource ManagementAll documents related to the abusive conduct investigation conducted by the Utah Department of Human Resource Management into alleged behavior by Mr. Onysko.Order of Continuance
434https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-4117-41Steven Onysko vs. Utah Department of Human Resource ManagementAppeal Denied
435https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-4217-42David Larsen vs. Heber City Police DepartmentMulti-media copy of videotaped footage from the Police Department’s lobby area.Appeal Denied
436https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-4317-43Steven Maese, Wasatch Constable's Office, vs. Weber State UniversityCopies of all records detailing FERPA directory information for all students enrolled in the POST academy for the last two years.Appeal Partially Granted
437https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-4417-44Robert Gehrke, Salt Lake Tribune, vs. Kane CountyAny maps prepared by Kane County as well as any correspondence regarding the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument sent or received since Jan. 1, 2017, between government officials.Appeal Partially Granted
438https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-4517-45Wanda G. Amann vs. Utah Independent Executive Branch Ethics CommissionRecords related to the related to the hiring, retaining, employing, or contracting of Chuck Conrad as legal counsel for the Commission.Appeal Denied
439https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-4617-46Aaron David Trent Needham vs. Utah Department of Commerce, Division of Occupational and Professional LicensingRecords held by the Division of Occupational and Professional Licensing.Appeal Dismissed
440https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-4717-47Mike Anderson, KSL-TV vs. Kaysville City Police DepartmentPolice body camera footage from February 12, 2017, where an individual may have been involved in an altercation (“suspect”) with police officers inside that person’s home.Appeal Granted
441https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-4817-48Edward A. Berkovich vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeA copy of an October 19, 2015, Memorandum from the Directory of the Utah Prosecution Council (“UPC”), to UPC members regarding Petitioner’s employment status.Appeal Dismissed
442https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-4917-49Steven Onysko vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeRecords related to a memorandum prepared by an employee of the Utah Division of Environmental Quality regarding an incident that occurred on November 9, 2016.Appeal Denied
443https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=17-5017-50Albert Cramer vs. Utah Attorney General's Office(1) The documents created to report Petitioner's concerns to Sean Reyes…; (2) Mail log for this letter; (3) Sean Reyes response or instructions to his attorney about Petitioner's concerns; (4) Any other records created as a result of Petitioner's concerns about AG Attorneys.Appeal Denied
444https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-0118-01Steven Onysko vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeRecords related to the Respondent’s handling of a whistle-blower lawsuit styled USA ex. rel. Mark Christopher Tracy v. Emigration Improvement District et al., No. 2:14-cv-00701 (D. Utah); plus an additional request for Multi-Agency State Office Building (MASOB) visitor log records.Appeal Denied
445https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-0218-02Steven Onysko vs. Utah Department of Environmental QualityAll computer metadata pertaining to an electronic document created and disseminated from DEQ-controlled computer facilities, purportedly by [a] DEQ employee.Appeal Denied
446https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-0318-03Eric Peterson, Utah Investigative Journalism Project vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeThe final and completed Utah Attorney General’s Office 2012 UTA Investigation Report regarding allegations of impropriety and insider dealings involving former UTA board members including Terry Diehl and Greg Hughes.Appeal Denied
447https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-0418-04Brady Eames vs. Logan CityAny and all FCC Forms 394 associated with any transfer of cable television franchise since December 30, 1984.Appeal Denied
448https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-0518-05Evan Johnson vs. Sandy CityLegal and PR invoices for the time period of Jan 1, 2016 to present. Appeal was in relation to fees.Appeal Denied
449https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-0618-06Mine Shaft Brewing PC vs. Summit CountyRecords and information relating to the Blue Ribbon Commission.Appeal Denied
450https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-0718-07Eric Peterson, Utah Investigative Journalism Project, vs. Salt Lake City Police DepartmentUnredacted copies of reports previously provided to Petitioner regarding a cold case investigation of a specific person and case number.Appeal Denied
451https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-0818-08Jon Hagen, H-Wire Technology Solutions, vs. Capstone Classical Academy, Ogden, UtahRecords related to a Request for Proposal (“RFP”) for IT Services posted by Respondent on October 25, 2017.Appeal Denied
452https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-0918-09John Tilleman vs. Ogden CityRecords including witness statements.Appeal Partially Granted
453https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-1018-10Ben Empey, Independent Journalist, vs. Utah Department of Environmental Quality, Division of Waste Management and Radiation ControlRecords relating to landfill information in the State of Utah.Appeal Denied
454https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-1118-11Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Division of Public UtilitiesA number of documents and communications, as well as a search of the Google Vault for said documents and communications. Petitioner also requested a waiver of fees.Appeal Denied
455https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-1218-12Scott Gollaher vs. Morgan County Attorney's OfficeCopies, bills or payments made to petitioner's appellant council, Ron Fujino or Bryan Baron.Appeal Denied
456https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-1318-13McKhelyn Jones, The UVU Review vs. Utah Valley UniversityRecords regarding a specific person’s employment status, complaints/audits made against said person or the Title IX office, and the redaction of a document showing said person’s annualized base pay.Appeal Partially Granted
457https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-1418-14Gizmodo Media Group vs. Department of Commerce, Division of Occupational and Professional LicensingRecords related to complaints, investigations and citations regarding a specific individual.Appeal Denied
458https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-1518-15ACLU of Utah and the Disability Law Center vs. Davis CountyAll written standards used or relied upon by Davis County in its administration and operation of the Davis County Jail at any time during the past five (5) years, including but not limited to the Utah Jail Standards; plus related emails, reports, and audits.Appeal Partially GrantedSee also court case ruling.https://archives.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/Davis-County-v-ACLU-Court-Decision.pdf
459https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-1618-16Scott Gollaher vs. Morgan County Attorney's OfficeAll communications, billing records received and payments made to, from or concerning [a specific individual] and [an Appellate and District Case No.] from March 1, 2016 to the date of reply to this request, including but not limited to email, invoices, payment records, transmittals, etc.Order of Continuance
460https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-1718-17Tax Analysts vs. Utah State Tax CommissionAll field audit manuals and audit training manuals that were used from January 1, 2011 to the present in the formats (electronic or otherwise) in which they are maintained.Appeal Denied
461https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-1818-18Leonard Platt vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAny and all records pertaining to the investigation of all allegations of criminal conduct committed by Chad Lester Platt from January 1, 2012 to May 9, 2016.Order of Continuance
462https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-1918-19Ken Cromar vs. Cedar HillsAll public records regarding all individuals or groups who have golfed for FREE at the Cedar Hills owned golf course over the past three years.Appeal Denied
463https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-2018-20Ben Empey vs. Box Elder CountyAll documents related to the Promontory Landfill since January 1, 2013 including all written communications between specific individuals using specified key words. The request also included communications “between any Box Elder employee.”Appeal Denied
464https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-2118-21Michael Clara vs. Utah State Board of EducationA copy of the School Resource Officer and School Administrators Training Curriculum; as well as records relating to the purchasing of training curriculum from vendors or consultants. Additionally, copied of documentation demonstrating an alleged conflice of interest that Dr. Prospero has in the development of that curriculum.Appeal Granted
465https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-2218-22Jeremy Flygare vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAll records referencing petitioner's involvement in SOTP and Resolve including reports, summaries, test results, interview notes, meeting minutes, e-mails, and [sic] statements concerning him.Appeal Denied
466https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-2318-23Kimball Bennion, KUTV News vs. Brigham Young University Police DepartmentA copy of a 2017 interview by Respondent with Joseph L. Bishop.Appeal Granted
467https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-2418-24Ethan Dodge, Truth and Transparency Foundation vs. Brigham Young University Police DepartmentAll files, videos, audio recordings, or any other kind of documentation related to allegations against Joseph L. Bishop.Appeal Granted
468https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-2518-25Corbin T. Voluz vs. Brigham Young University Police DepartmentAll records relating to a specific incident report relating to the investigation of a specific person in November and December of 2017.Appeal Granted
469https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-2618-26Nelson Brown vs. Weber Area Dispatch 911 and Emergency ServicesRecord of a phone call made by an individual requesting sheriffs deputies to respond to the petitioner's house located at a specific location, Monday evening, 26 February 2018.Appeal Denied
470https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-2718-27Scott Gollaher vs. Morgan County Attorney's OfficeOrder of Continuance
471https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-2818-28Leonard Platt vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAny and all records pertaining to the investigation of all allegations of criminal conduct committed by Chad Lester Platt from January 1, 2012 to May 9, 2016.Appeal Partially Granted
472https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-2918-29Scott Gollaher vs. Morgan County Attorney's OfficeAll communications, billing records received and payments made to, from or concerning [a specific individual] and [an Appellate and District Case No.] from March 1, 2016 to the date of reply to this request, including but not limited to email, invoices, payment records, transmittals, etc. by and employee/official of Morgan County.Appeal Denied
473https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-3018-30Nick Schou, Utah Rivers Council vs. Kane County Water Conservancy DistrictEleven years’ worth of correspondence between Executive Director, Mr. Mike Noel, alongside other staff and board members, and other specified persons.Appeal Granted
474https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-3118-31Chad Bennion vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeRecords regarding 2014 Senate Bill 54.Order of Continuance
475https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-3218-32Chad Bennion vs. Governor's OfficeRecords regarding 2014 Senate Bill 54.Order of Continuance
476https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-3318-33Chad Bennion vs. Lt. Governor's OfficeRecords regarding 2014 Senate Bill 54.Order of Continuance
477https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-3418-34Randy Andrus, Leon Brown's Estate vs. Unified Police DepartmentAll communications, records, and documents related to an incident occurring on September 22, 2016.Order of Continuance
478https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-3518-35Chad Bennion vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeRecords indicating the balance, revenues and expenditures of the Attorney General Litigation Fund for the purpose of providing funds to pay for any costs and expenses incurred by the state attorney general in relation to actions under state or federal antitrust, criminal laws, or civil proceedings, for the 2014, 2015 and 2016, including the current balance of the fund.Appeal Partially Granted
479https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-3618-36Raphael Cordray vs. Utah School and Institutional Trust Lands AdministrationRecords pertaining to a retreat held by SITLA Board of Trustees in January 2018.Appeal Denied
480https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-3718-37Scott Gollaher vs. Morgan CountyRecords and information, in any form, that refer to or implicate [Mr. Gollaher] as a subject in a record of Morgan County.Appeal Denied
481https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-3818-38Raymond Clinton vs. Tooele School DistrictAll records and correspondence the Stansbury High School Principal had relating to the Stansbury High Baseball program and Mr. Clinton as the former coach.Appeal Partially Granted
482https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-3918-39Elias Faraclas vs. Lehi CityAll electronic communications, including cell phone text messages, sent and received by Paul Hancock during the city council meeting on 1/16/18.Appeal Granted
483https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-4018-40People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals and Students for Animal Welfare vs. University of UtahRecords relating to the “University of Utah’s use of animals in experimentation.” Petitioners provided a detailed description of the specific records that were being requested.Appeal Granted
484https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-4118-41Simonsen Law, on behalf of Lynn David vs. Wasatch CountyRecords relating to funds received by Wasatch County from the State of Utah Transient Room Tax including details of how the funds were spent by Wasatch CountyAppeal Denied
485https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-4218-42Brady Eames vs. Nibley CityRecords relating to any and all documentation of the penal bonds which have been issued, any and all documentation of the oaths of office, and any and all respective agreements relating to the Utah Local Governments’ Trust (“ULGT”)Appeal Granted
486https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-4318-43Brady Eames vs. Providence CityRecords relating to any and all documentation of the penal bonds which have been issued, any and all documentation of the oaths of office, and any and all respective agreements relating to the Utah Local Governments’ Trust (“ULGT”)Appeal Granted
487https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-4418-44Brady Eames vs. Wellsville CityRecords relating to any and all documentation of the penal bonds which have been issued, any and all documentation of the oaths of office, and any and all respective agreements relating to the Utah Local Governments’ Trust (“ULGT”)Appeal Withdrawn
488https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-4518-45Brady Eames vs. Hyde Park CityRecords relating to any and all documentation of the penal bonds which have been issued, any and all documentation of the oaths of office, and any and all respective agreements relating to the Utah Local Governments’ Trust (“ULGT”)Appeal Granted
489https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-4618-46Brady Eames vs. Millville CityRecords relating to any and all documentation of the penal bonds which have been issued, any and all documentation of the oaths of office, and any and all respective agreements relating to the Utah Local Governments’ Trust (“ULGT”)Appeal Granted
490https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-4718-47Brady Eames vs. North Logan CityRecords relating to any and all documentation of the penal bonds which have been issued, any and all documentation of the oaths of office, and any and all respective agreements relating to the Utah Local Governments’ Trust (“ULGT”)Appeal Granted
491https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-4818-48Brady Eames vs. Richmond CityRecords relating to any and all documentation of the penal bonds which have been issued, any and all documentation of the oaths of office, and any and all respective agreements relating to the Utah Local Governments’ Trust (“ULGT”)Appeal Granted
492https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-4918-49Brady Eames vs. River Heights CityRecords relating to any and all documentation of the penal bonds which have been issued, any and all documentation of the oaths of office, and any and all respective agreements relating to the Utah Local Governments’ Trust (“ULGT”)Appeal Denied
493https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-5018-50Brady Eames vs. Tremonton CityRecords relating to any and all documentation of the penal bonds which have been issued, any and all documentation of the oaths of office, and any and all respective agreements relating to the Utah Local Governments’ Trust (“ULGT”)Appeal Granted
494https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-5118-51Wayne Crawford vs. Salt Lake CountyUnredacted copies of photographs related to a specific Salt Lake County Code Enforcement case.Appeal Denied
495https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-5218-52Kit Kosakowski vs. Wasatch CountyRecords relating to questions raised and/or comments made during a September 11, 2017 meeting and a September 20, 2017 public hearing.Appeal Denied
496https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-5318-53Michael Clara vs. Salt Lake City Mayor's OfficeCopies of the data and information used to reach the conclusion that a road diet be implemented for 900 West in Salt Lake City. Mr. Clara also requested a fee waiver.Appeal Granted
497https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-5418-54Brady Eames vs. Millville CityTo access and inspect certain opinions, interpretations and correspondences regarding penal bonds executed and filed by certain persons elected or appointed as certain officers.Appeal Granted
498https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-5518-55Brady Eames vs. Richmond CityTo access and inspect certain opinions, interpretations and correspondences regarding penal bonds executed and filed by certain persons elected or appointed as certain officers.Appeal Granted
499https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-5618-56Brady Eames vs. Hyde Park CityTo access and inspect certain opinions, interpretations and correspondences regarding penal bonds executed and filed by certain persons elected or appointed as certain officers.Appeal Granted
500https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-5718-57Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAll incident reports, initial contact reports, IR-1, IR-2, etc. from 6-1-18 to present, up to $8.00 worth.Appeal Denied
501https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-5818-58Brady Eames vs. Tremonton CityTo access and inspect certain opinions, interpretations and correspondences regarding penal bonds executed and filed by certain persons elected or appointed as certain officers.Appeal Granted
502https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-5918-59Brady Eames vs. Utah Local Governments TrustAny and all faithful performance bonds and/or indemnification bonds and/or other bonds required by any Utah law which have been acquired and filed by any elected and public officers.Appeal Denied
503https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-6018-60Brady Eames vs. Smithfield CityTo access and inspect certain opinions, interpretations and correspondences regarding penal bonds executed and filed by certain persons elected or appointed as certain officers.Appeal Granted
504https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-6118-61Brady Eames vs. Utah Local Governments TrustElectronic access to public records related to public officials’ bonds, oaths, and interlocal ULGT records.Appeal Denied
505https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-6218-62Lyle Fletcher vs. Utah CountyRecords relating to a specific criminal case.Appeal Denied
506https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=18-6318-63Brady Eames vs. Salt Lake City CorporationCopies of all executed and filed public official penal bonds and all subscribed and filed constitutional oaths of office of certain elected and appointed City officers.Appeal Denied
507https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-0119-01Scott Gollaher vs. Morgan CountyRecords relating to Certificates of Insurance, payments and/or invoices and/or any accounting records relating to specific persons doing business with Respondent, Morgan County.Order of Continuance
508https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-0219-02Janae Wahnschaffe vs. Highland CityCorrespondences to and from specific individuals including the mayor of Highland City, copies of investigative written reports, signed affidavits, a presentation given during a board meeting, and copies of outgoing text messages from a specific person.Appeal Granted
509https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-0319-03Scott Gollaher vs. Morgan CountyRecords relating to Certificates of Insurance, payments and/or invoices and/or any accounting records relating to specific persons doing business with Respondent, Morgan County.Appeal Denied
510https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-0419-04Brady Eames vs. West Valley CityAny and all executed and filed public official penal bonds and any and all subscribed and filed constitutional oaths of office of certain elected and appointed officers.Appeal Denied
511https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-0519-05Brady Eames vs. Ogden CityAny and all executed and filed public official penal bonds and any and all subscribed and filed constitutional oaths of office of certain elected and appointed officers.Appeal Denied
512https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-0619-06Edward A. Berkovich vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeThe “freeconferencecall.com” recording of a Utah Prosecution Council (UPC) Board meeting held on October 21, 2015 to discuss the “character, professional competence, or physical or mental health” of the petitioner and his continued employment with UPC.Appeal Denied
513https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-0719-07Brady Eames vs. Utah Local Government TrustNumerous emails to/from specific individuals relating to Respondent.Appeal Denied
514https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-0819-08Taylor Stevens, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Grantsville CityAny and all documents and final reports pertaining to the outside investigation into Mayor Brent Marshall’s behavior.Appeal Partially Granted
515https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-0919-09Anthony Fierro vs. Salt Lake School DistrictRecords allegedly held by respondent.Order of Continuance
516https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-1019-10Chad Benion vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAll records demonstrating costs, fees, charges or payment, incurred by the Attorney General's Office in any litigation regarding Senate Bill 54 (2014).Appeal Denied
517https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-1119-11Janalee Raelynn Roberts vs. Utah Department of Human Services. Division of Child and Family ServicesFinal reports for DCFS Case numbers 2446067 or 244758, and for records related to an interview conducted by the Children’s Justice Center on July 12, 2018 including the final report findings.Appeal Denied
518https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-1219-12Douglas Sagers vs. Tooele CountyCounty audited and unaudited financial records, budges, contracts, management agreements, leases, purchase orders, invoices for equipment, O&M, vehicles, marketing, operating supplies, restaurant furnishings and equipment, ATVS, computers, contracts and agreements entered into between Tooele County and lessees, managers, contractors, consultants, professional service providers, appraisers, and or other parties involved or retained by Tooele County to manage, assist, consult, or advise Tooele County in the operation and or sale of the Tooele County Owned Utah Motorsports Park.Appeal Granted
519https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-1319-13Eric Peterson vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeRecords allegedly held by Respondent, the Utah Attorney General’s Office.Order of Continuance
520https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-1419-14Judith Zimmerman vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAny and all documentation of disciplinary action taken against four individuals who were current or former employees of the AG’s Office.Appeal Denied
521https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-1519-15Bill Keshlear vs. San Juan CountyRecords related to a meeting of the San Juan County Commission on February 5, 2019.Appeal Granted
522https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-1619-16Joshua Althoff vs. Moab CityAn Internal Affairs Investigation Report in its entirety, including polygraph reports and recordings.Appeal Partially Granted
523https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-1719-17Tony Alexander Hamilton vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsThe contract between the UDC and the contract attorneys, Wayne Freestone and David Angerhofer.Appeal Denied
524https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-1819-18Seven Wilson vs. Tooele CityAll supplements [sic], investigative reports, narrative statements, opening statements, D.N.A results, and discoveries for a specific case.Appeal Denied
525https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-1919-19Michael Bacon vs. Utah Deparment of CorrectionsPolicy that governs that allows inmates to send out urine analysis to an outside independent lab to be re-tested.Appeal Denied
526https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-2019-20Elias Faraclas vs. Lehi CityThe TMTH Development Agreement and all records relating to the Agreement between January 16, 2018 and the signing of the Agreement.Appeal Granted
527https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-2119-21Eric Peterson vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeOrder of Continuance
528https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-2219-22Eric Peterson vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeOrder of Continuance
529https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-2319-23Rolf Kaestel vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAll diabetes-related diagnostics in petitioner's file between 1999 and December 31, 2007. Also, a fee waiver for the records.Appeal Denied
530https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-2419-24Oswald Balfour vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsRecords relating to petitioner including notes, assessments, reports, case action plans, post-conviction reports, and communications.Appeal Denied
531https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-2519-25Gordon Thomas vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsMental health records relating to petitioner.Order of Continuance
532https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-2619-26Leroy Wirz vs. Utah State Tax CommissionRecords relating to an investigator’s closing report and findings for a specific case number.Appeal Granted
533https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-2719-27Utah News Now vs. Governor's Office of Economic DevelopmentDocuments related to Josh Romney in electronic form via email attachment.Appeal Denied
534https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-2819-28Judith Zimmerman vs. Utah Department of HealthRecords relating to original, signed copies of an e-mail chain that involved previous Department employees.Appeal Granted
535https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-2919-29Gordon Thomas vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsMedical records of petitioner.Appeal Partially Granted
536https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-3019-30Daniel McMann vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsA police report and assault charges on a specific person along with a specific person’s plea agreement.Order of Continuation
537https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-3119-31Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of Corrections1. List (index, glossary, table of contents) for all files, documents, reports, etc. stored in LEB track for two specific case numbers. 2. Investigative Report, Addendum and Attachments for a specific case number.Appeal Denied
538https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-3219-32Andrew Gulliford vs. San Juan CountyRecords related to the Bears Ears National Monument from 2016 – 2018 for:1. All work products, opinions, and documents sent to the county by Davillier Law Group; 2. Billing and hourly rates of the attorneys not on the county payroll; 3. Copies of all written correspondence including emails between the Davillier Group and San Juan County; and 4. Copies of Contracts with the attorneys involved.Order of Continuance
539https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-3319-33Kim Henderson vs. San Juan CountyAll communication between Kenneth Maryboy, Steve Boos and R. Atene during SJC Commission Meeting on April 2, 2019 from 9am to 1:30 pm, text and email.Appeal Granted
540https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-3419-34Jessica Miller, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Brigham Young University Police DepartmentRecords related to emails between BYU PD and a list of eight specific persons.Order of Continuance
541https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-3519-35Karra Porter, Utah Cold Case Coalition vs. Beaver County Sheriff's OfficeRecords relating to the murder of Karen Lee Jarvis, which occurred on or about February 8, 1998.Order of Continuance
542https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-3619-36Daniel McMann vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsA police report and assault charges on a specific person, along with that specific person’s plea agreement.Appeal Denied
543https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-3719-37McKhelyn Jones, UVU Review vs. Utah Valley UniversityEight initial contact reports from the UVU Police Department regarding specific incidents involving the UVU Police Department, plus a fee waiver as a member of the media.Appeal Granted
544https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-3819-38Michael Robinson vs. Sandy CityAll records regarding the investigation, charging, and the dismissal of a criminal case in which he was one of the victims.Appeal Denied
545https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-3919-39Brent Cobb vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsRecords related to investigation reports, and a fee waiver.Appeal Denied
546https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-4019-40Kelly Pehrson vs. San Juan CountyRecords relating to quotes provided by San Juan County Commissioner Kenneth Maryboy, attorney Steven Boos, and James Adakai, in a Salt Lake Tribune article and a press release purporting to be from Mr. Adakai.Appeal Granted
547https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-4119-41Paul Amann vs. Unified Police Department of Greater Salt Lake CityRecords relating to an investigation performed by Detective Dan Child “as referenced in an email dated June 12, 2017 at 8:15 a.m. from AG ICAC agent Alan White.”Order of Continuance
548https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-4219-42Yassine Ibrahim vs. Unified Police Department of Greater Salt Lake CitySalt Lake County Jail medical records, jail records, and booking records concerning an individual.Order of Continuance
549https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-4319-43Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsPictures of Talon Hamann (an inmate) from 2012 to present; Initial contact reports, incident reports, IR-1, IR-2, and Narratives for Mr. Hamann; All “c-notes” for Mr. Hamann; and All Offender History Reports for Mr. Hamann from 2012 to present.Appeal Partially Granted
550https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-4419-44Steven Onysko vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeCall records from April 1, 2018 through June 30, 2018 for a cellphone assigned to the former Civil Chief Deputy of the AG’s Office.Appeal Denied
551https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-4519-45Courtney Tanner vs. West Valley CityOrder of Continuance
552https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=19-4619-46Riley Booker vs. Davis CountyVideo and audio recordings from the booking room of the Davis County Jail Buildingon July 16, 2019.Appeal Granted
553https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-0120-01Tiffany Gilman vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAny records that could be released for research regarding Theodore “Ted” Bundy regarding his time as an inmate at the Utah State Prison.Appeal Granted
554https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-0220-02Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsA new policy FD20 for the privilege level system (privilege level matrix) … a copy of the policy itself … along with new matrix guideline. … [and] emails, correspondence, memorandums and letters regarding this new policy, specifically explaining or dealing with why the new policy has yet to take effect.Order of Continuance
555https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-0320-03Andrew Gulliford vs. San Juan County CommissionersOrder of Continuance
556https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-0420-04Garfield County's Taxpayer Association vs. Utah Tax CommissionCopies of the records which were used to calculate Garfield County’s statistics as presented in the 2019 Assessment/Sales Ratio Study. Such records would include the 33 residential and 46 vacant land surveys which were returned to, collected by and used by the Property Tax Division in the calculations… Pins of the 79 properties and copies of all correspondence between the Property Tax Division and the Garfield County Tax Assessor’s office relating to the 2019 Assessment/Sales Ratio Study, including email, spreadsheets, forms, or written requests.Appeal Granted
557https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-0520-05Cathryn Raphael Cordray vs. Seven County Infrastructure CoalitionRecords relating to the Uinta Basin Railroad Project.Request Denied
558https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-0620-06Center for Biological Diversity vs. Seven County Infrastructure CoalitionCommunications between Respondent and the Utah Department of Transportation and/or TYR Energy containing specific phrases of the Uinta Basin Railway Project, as well as a fee waiver.Appeal Granted
559https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-0720-07Mike Favero vs. Logan City School DistrictAny and all legal expenses” the District had paid, which legal firms had been paid, how many hours were billed, and “any other information you have in regards to any legal expenses.Appeal Granted
560https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-0820-08Paul Amann vs. Unified Police Department of Greater Salt LakeA computer hard drive in the possession of Respondent.Order of Continuance
561https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-0920-09Paul Amann vs. Unified Police Department of Greater Salt LakeRecords of communications regarding a specified report of Respondent and all records or communications to and from the Utah Attorney General’s Office (“AG’s Office”) regarding the report.Appeal Granted
562https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-1020-10Paul Amann vs. Unified Police Department of Greater Salt LakeA computer hard drive in the possession of Respondent.Order of Continuance
563https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-1120-11Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsRecords allegedly held by Respondent, the Utah Department of Corrections.Appeal Partially Granted
564https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-1220-12Ai-Ning Hsu vs. Utah Division of Child and Family ServicesRecords related to specific cases regarding Protective Supervision Services and Foster Care, and a fee waiver.Appeal Granted
565https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-1320-13Raymond Fitzgerald vs. Utah Division of Consumer ProtectionRecords relating to a Complaint that was filed against Day Pacer, LLC including an unredacted copy of the Complaint.Appeal Denied
566https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-1420-14John G. Bloom vs. Utah Division of Oil, Gas, and MiningTwo reports: (1) The May 2008 “Western Energy Hub Project Area, Structural Interpretation” prepared by Serra GeoConsulting LLC for Magnum Energy LLC; and (2) The August 2016 “Location and Character of Faults in the Vicinity of the Magnum Energy Facility” by author Steven Schamel.Appeal Denied
567https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-1520-15Kent Singleton vs. Riverdale CityCopies of the policies and procedures for operating a business in the Riverdale Senior Center (“Center”) and the contract between the Center and the Newsletter Advertisement Agency from 2016 to 2019.Appeal Denied
568https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-1620-16Eric Peterson vs. Utah Department of Natural ResourcesExpenditure reports from Big Game Forever from 2015 to the present and any conflict of interest statements filed by Big Game Forever since the organization began receiving Utah state funds.Appeal Granted
569https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-1720-17Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsRecords relating to emails sent and received by certain Correctional Facility employees during a specified time frame.Appeal Granted
570https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-1820-18Cody Young vs. Juab CountyRecords relating to petitioner's arrest and/or incarceration.Appeal Denied
571https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-1920-19Chad Bennion vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeRecords regarding “costs, fees, charges, payments, etc.,” “time, costs, or billable hours,” “litigation costs, expenditures, payments” and “request[s] to confer or for consultation” related to Senate Bill 54 Elections Amendments (2014 Sessions) (“SB54”).Appeal Denied
572https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-2020-20Corbin Volluz vs. Brigham Young UniversityOrder of Continuance
573https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-2120-21Scott Gollaher vs. Morgan CountyAny and all records/documents from January 1, 2008 through the date of response to this request for claims or lawsuits which resulted in a payout of $1,000 or more against the Morgan County Sheriff’s Office.Appeal Granted
574https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-2220-22Corbin Volluz vs. Brigham Young UniversityRecords related to a specific police investigation undertaken by Respondent.Appeal Denied
575https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-2320-23Jill McKlusky vs. University of UtahAll student counseling records regarding Lauren McCluskey, including but not limited to records from the University Counseling Center and the Psychology and Wellness service. Also, any other records that might indicate who had accessed Lauren McCluskey’s counselling records.Appeal Granted
576https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-2420-24Mark Gajkowski vs. Utah State Tax CommissionAll investigation documents, officer notes, and reports regarding a specific investigation case.Appeal Denied
577https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-2520-25Sheila Canavan vs. San Juan CountyLocal referendum petition signature packets with redactions made for birth dates of signatories.Appeal Granted
578https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-2620-26Daniel Movahhed vs. Salt Lake County Sheriff's OfficeOrder of Continuance
579https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-2720-27Kent Singleton vs. Weber Human ServicesPersonal and business cell phone texts, emails, conversations, trainings/meetings/minutes, notes and data of any communications concerning accusations made that the petitioner and Jeff Glum inappropriately used Riverdale Senior Center computers in 2019.Appeal Denied
580https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-2820-28Charles Bascomb vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsDocuments related to Mr. Bascomb’s incarceration in the Draper and Gunnison corrections facilities.Appeal Denied
581https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-2920-29Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsOrder of Continuance
582https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-3020-30Danial Movahhed vs. Salt Lake CountyDocumentation regarding the justification to continue petitioner's housing assignment in administrative segregation and the associated reviews.Appeal Denied
583https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-3120-31Trevor Lee vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsVarious records and communications, most of which related to Patrick Sullivan. Mr. Lee also requested a fee waiver because Mr. Sullivan is the subject of the records and is impecunious.Appeal Partially Granted
584https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-3220-32Blake Johnson vs. Judicial Conduct CommissionAll documents, decisions, findings, conclusions, etc. related to the investigation into Honorable Thomas L. Kay and his conduct regarding Roush vs. Greene’s Inc., Case No. 160700091. Trial took place September 25-26, 2017. The conduct investigated occurred at the Post Trial Hearing that took place on January 19, 2018.Appeal Dismissed
585https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-3320-33Wasatch Taxpayer Association vs. Wasatch County School DistrictRecords related to the “Bio-West Wetlands Delineation Report” prepared for Respondent related to a proposed new high school in Wasatch County.Appeal Granted
586https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-3420-34Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsOrder of Continuance
587https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-3520-35Brady Eames vs. Utah Local Government's TrustAccounting records and records regarding a specific individual’s employment with ULGT over a period of 17.5 years.Appeal Denied
588https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-3620-36Brady Eames vs. Logan CityWritten reports documenting any and all deposits and investments made by the Public Treasurer of Respondent with the State Money Management Council from 2010 through 2020. Mr. Eames also requested a fee waiver for inspection of the written reports.Appeal Granted
589https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-3720-37Sue Steel and Roni Wilcox vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAll e-mail sent or received by Corrections’ employees regarding Petitioners from September 1, 2019 to the present.Appeal Denied
590https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-3820-38Center for Biological Diversity vs. Department of Workforce ServicesRecords related to the Uinta Basin Railway including its funding and communications by the Community Impact Fund Board. Petitioner also requested a fee waiverAppeal Granted
591https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-3920-39Salt Lake Legal Defenders Association vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyRecords relating to the Intoxilyzer 8000 used by the Utah Highway Patrol.Appeal Denied
592https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-4020-40Center for Biological Diversity vs. Department of Workforce ServicesOrder of Continuance
593https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-4120-41Paul Richins vs. Davis CountyAll “tangible” and “intangible” records related to Respondent’s valuation of his real property.Appeal Denied
594https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-4220-42Larry Agee vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsEmployee misconduct record concerning a specific employee for Corrections from 2012 to 2019.Appeal Denied
595https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-4320-43KSL-TV vs. Utah Department of HealthAll complaints regarding nursing homes from Feb. 1, 2020 to current date for the purpose of obtaining information on how nursing homes are handling COVID and notifying residents’ families.Appeal Granted
596https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-4420-44Steven Onysko vs. Emigration Improvement DistrictAll records and documents relating to lead in, including but not limited to, lead contamination of, public drinking water in Emigration Improvement District.Appeal Denied
597https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-4520-45Mike Favero vs. Logan City School DistrictAll emails and text messages exchanged to and or from Superintendent Frank Schofield, Principal Ken Auld and Board member Ann Geary on Logan City Schools Districts computers or cell phones.Appeal Partially Granter
598https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-4620-46Raphael Cordray vs. Utah Inland Port AuthorityEmails, correspondence, other paper or electronic records, maps, memos, reports, photographs, depictions, and graphs containing referencing or referring to any electronic meeting, policy, plan or discussion that was had…zoom room, virtual meetings, and online meetings” during a specific time frame. Also requested records created or distributed for the purpose of facilitating an electronic meeting.Appeal Granted
599https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-4720-47Brady Eames vs. Utah Local Governments TrustRecords related to ULGT Board meetings held on August 25, 2017 and October 27, 2017.Appeal Denied
600https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-4820-48KSL-5 News vs. Layton City Police DepartmentA copy of the 911 phone call from Ethan Hunsaker made on May 26, 2020. The record is related to the death of Ashlyn Black.Appeal Denied
601https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-4920-49Nicole Noren, ESPN vs. University of UtahCopies of records held by Respondent relating to the murder of University of Utah student Lauren McCluskey.Appeal Granted
602https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-5020-50Leo Holtz vs. Utah State Treasurer's OfficePublic records of the Surplus / Excess Funds list (7 years of data) from tax foreclosure sale auctions conducted by counties, whose unclaimed surplus funds have been transferred to and held by the Utah State Treasury.Appeal Denied
603https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-5120-51Alexander Cramer vs. Summit CountyOrder of Continuance
604https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-5220-52Ozwald Balfour vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsEntries in Correction's Offender History Report made after 04/21/2016 to present.Order of Continuance
605https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-5320-53Brady Eames vs. Utah League of Cities and TownsAny and all documentation of any rules of order and procedure with respect to the open and public meetings convened by the Respondent’s Board of Directors or any other public body of Respondent.Appeal Denied
606https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-5420-54Steven Onysko vs. Utah Department of Environmental Quality, Division of Drinking WaterAll records and documents related to lead contamination in public drinking water from the Emigration Improvement District.Appeal Denied
607https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-5520-55Center for Biological Diversity vs. Seven County Infrastructure CoalitionRecords related to the Uinta Basin Railway Project including memoranda, studies, findings, and minutes.Appeal Denied
608https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-5620-56Brady Eames vs. Utah State TreasurerWritten reports documenting any and all deposits and investments made by the State Treasurer as filed with the State Money Management Council on or before January 31st and July 31st of 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, and 2019. Also, written reports filed by the State Treasurer with the State Money Management Council which include: (1) The amount of public funds in the possession or control of the State Treasurer; (2) The details of the nature and extent of the deposit and investment of such public funds; and (3) The details of the rate of return on each deposit or investment of such public funds.Appeal Denied
609https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-5720-57Brady Eames vs. Utah State TreasurerFinancial institution records pertaining to the transfer of citizens tax money to the Public Treasurer’s Investment Fund from the following institutes of higher education: Utah State University, the University of Utah, Weber State University, Southern Utah University, Snow College, Dixie State University, Utah Valley University, and Salt Lake Community College. Also all FINET records and investment income pertaining to the transfer of citizens tax money to the PTIF from the above named institutes of higher education.Appeal Denied
610https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-5820-58J. Robert Latham vs. Utah Department of Human ServicesThe Office of Quality and design’s source material for specific statements contained in its 2018 and 2019 Southwest Qualitative Case Review (“QCR”) reports.Appeal Denied
611https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-5920-59Steven Onysko vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAll records and documentation relating to alteration, changes, reprogramming, deactivation, or other conduct with respect to a former Civil Deputy’s building access cards.Appeal Denied
612https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-6020-60Steven Onysko vs. Attorney General's OfficeAll records and documentation relating to State agents’, including but not limited to Office of Attorney General’s agents’, unsuccessful and successful contact of the former Civil Deputy, any time commenting April 6, 2018 (her purported separation date from State service) for purpose of the State, including any of its OAG or other agents, making injury or other communication vis-à-vis the State building access card, cellphone and computer laptop still in the former Civil Chief Deputy’s possession or control through the purported May 22, 2018, theft of this property, reported in Unified Police Greater Salt Lake report.Appeal Granted
613https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-6120-61Sam Stecklow vs. Utah Division of Purchasing and General ServicesCopies of the applications, all documents, all addendums, and any amendments made to the applications for all medical cannabis cultivators and pharmacies that have been granted a license from the State to operate and the criteria by which the applications were scored, and the scoring documentation for each application that was awarded a license.Order of Continuance
614https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-6220-62Alexander Cramer vs. Summit CountyPetitioner, on behalf of The Park Record, requested correspondence between April 13, 2020 and May 1, 2020 regarding Respondent’s Joint Public Health Order 2020-05 issued on April 30, 2020, and a fee waiver for said records.Appeal Granted
615https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-6320-63Taylor Hartman, Utah Investigative Journalism Project vs. Beaver Valley HospitalFinancial records of Beaver Valley Hospital including payees who received funding from the hospital, administrative fees and other charges including management charges by the hospital, and salary information for administrators.Appeal Partially Granted
616https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-6420-64Brady Eames vs. Utah Local Government TrustPlans, policies, reports, statements, and resolutions of the Utah Legal Government Trust Board regarding the use of tax money of Logan City’s and Cache County’s citizens.Appeal Denied
617https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-6520-65Jessica Miller, Salt Lake Tribune vs. West Valley City Police DepartmentAll body camera footage from Aug 23, 2019 police shootings of a specific individual.Order of Continuance
618https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=20-6620-66Utah Animal Rights Coalition vs. Utah Department of Agriculture & FoodOrder of Continuance
619https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-0121-01Luis Sanchez vs. West Valley Police DepartmentRecords regarding a specific incident involving the West Jordan Police Department, and a fee waiver for the records.Appeal Denied
620https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-0221-02Darren Rosenstein vs. Utah Department of TransportationOrder of Continuance
621https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-0321-03Jessica Miller, Salt Lake Tribune vs. West Valley City Police DepartmentSix videos related to the shooting of Michael Chad Breinholt while he was in police custody, resulting in his death on August 23, 2019.Appeal Granted
622https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-0421-04Brady Eames vs. Millard CountyRecords regarding the 1988 murder of Gordon Ray Church and the subsequent trials and convictions of Michael Anthony Archuleta and Lance Conway Wood. Mr. Eames requested that he be given access for inspection of the trial exhibits, stored at the county.Appeal Denied
623https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-0521-05Steven Onysko vs. Attorney General's OfficeOrder of Continuance
624https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-0621-06Utah Animal Rights Coalition vs. Department of Agriculture & FoodRecords regarding Utah mink farms including records detailing issues arising from the COVID-19 pandemic.Appeal Partially Granted
625https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-0721-07J. Robert Latham vs. Washington CountyOrder of Continuance
626https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-0821-08Darren Rosenstein vs. Utah Department of TransportationOrder of Continuance
627https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-0921-09Mark Tracy vs. Emigration Improvement District and Simplifi CompanyE-mail correspondence regarding lead contamination of water system 18143 and the use of public funds for private legal costs.Appeal Partially Granted
628https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-1021-10Steven Onysko vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeRecords regarding legal services procured by the AG’s Office from a specified law firm regarding legal matters related to Paul G. Amann.Appeal Partially Granted
629https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-1121-11Caralee Woods vs. Utah Department of Agriculture and FoodAny records regarding amendments to the Boulder Creek Canyon Ranch Conservation Easement (“BCCR Easement”).Appeal Granted
630https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-1221-12Darren Rosenstein vs. Utah Department of TransportationOrder of Continuance
631https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-1321-13Sandra Guzman-Ochoa vs. Utah Division of Child and Family ServicesOrder of Continuance
632https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-1421-14Tiffany Gilman vs. Unified Police DepartmentOrder of Continuance
633https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-1521-15Center for Biological Diversity vs. Department of Workforce ServicesOrder of Continuance
634https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-1621-16J. Robert Latham vs. Washington CountyRecords that referenced or were about the petitioner from two named individuals on or after June 20, 2018Appeal Denied
635https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-1721-17Steven Onysko vs. State Records CommitteeAll records related to the State Records Committee action combining two appeals Mr. Onysko had before the Committee in Onysko v. Attorney Gen.’s Office, State Records Committee Case No. 21-10 (Feb. 22, 2021).Appeal Denied
636https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-1821-18Devon Cantwell vs. University of UtahEmail correspondence between Respondent’s Office of Equal Opportunity and Nicole Bedera, a Ph.D. candidate at the University of MichiganAppeal Denied
637https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-1921-19Save Our Canyons vs. Utah Department of TransportationRecords related to the State Route 210 project in Little Cottonwood Canyon located in Salt Lake County.Order of Continuance
638https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-2021-20Sandra Guzman-Ochoa vs. Utah Division of Child and Family ServicesA copy of a 2020 case report and an earlier 2014 case report from Respondent. Both of the case reports involved Ms. Guzman-Ochoa or a member of her family.Appeal Partially Granted
639https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-2121-21Raphael Cordray vs. Duchesne CountyRecords from Respondent's Planning and Zoning Department about the Uinta Basin Railway Project, as well as a fee waiver.Appeal Denied
640https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-2221-22Tiffany Gilman vs. Unified Police DepartmentCopies of any records related to the missing person case of Nancy Wilcox.Appeal Granted
641https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-2321-23Sam Stecklow vs. Salt Lake City Police DepartmentDigitally maintained records regarding closed SLCPD officer incidents involving the use of force, firearm discharges, traffic collisions, and police-involved shootings including those resulting in death.Appeal Partially Granted
642https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-2421-24Sam Stecklow vs. Salt Lake City Police Department Civilian Review BoardDecisions and other final disposition documentation for cases reviewed by Respondent but not published on Salt Lake City’s website.Appeal Partially Granted
643https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-2521-25Sam Stecklow, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Clinton CityRecords regarding two current or former employees of the Clinton Police DepartmentAppeal Partially Granted
644https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-2621-26Sam Stecklow, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Washington County Sheriff's OfficeRecords regarding four specified officer critical incidents involving Washington County Sheriff Deputies during the past thirteen years.Appeal Partially Granted
645https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-2721-27Sam Stecklow vs. City of Cottonwood HeightsInternal investigatory records regarding three shootings involving officers of its police department.Appeal Granted
646https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-2821-28Sam Stecklow vs. West Jordan Police DepartmentInternal affairs or use of force reports and the final disposition from any such internal review.Appeal Granted
647https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-2921-29Darren Rosenstein vs. Utah Department of TransportationOrder of Continuance
648https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-3021-30Save Our Canyons vs. Utah Department of TransportationRecords related to the State Route 210 project in Little Cottonwood Canyon located in Salt Lake County.Order of Continuance
649https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-3121-31Donald Anderson vs. Department of Workforce ServicesRecords submitted to the Department of Workforce Services on November 20, 2020 by the Center for Family Evaluation and Treatment.Appeal Denied
650https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-3221-32Stephen Pace vs. Salt Lake CityMeeting minutes and the revisions to those minutes for the Salt Lake City Historic Landmark Commission’s July 16, 2020 public meeting.Appeal Denied
651https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-3321-33Stephen Pace vs. Salt Lake City CorporationRecords related to the former Salt Lake City Commission’s actions in the late 1970s to modify certain land use regulations.Appeal Denied
652https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-3421-34Robert Sloman vs. University of UtahOrder of Continuance
653https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-3521-35Darren Rosenstein vs. Utah Department of TransportationOrder of Continuance
654https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-3621-36Mark Allen vs. Utah CountyCopies of all cell phone texts between Utah County Commissioner Bill Lee and two specified individuals from January 1, 2020 to the date of the request. Petitioner also requested copies of all incoming and outgoing messages related to Bridal Veil Falls and public comments regarding Bridal Veil Falls between November 1, 2020 and December 14, 2020.Appeal Denied
655https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-3721-37Gary Eatchel vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsA copy of the Initial Contact Report (ICR), Incident Reports, Narratives, Attachments, and Supplements for incident/case #338525.Appeal Granted
656https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-3821-38Nimo Leauanae vs. Alpine School DistrictA copy of an investigative report conducted by Principal Erickson regarding the October 27, 2020 volleyball game incident.Appeal Partially Granted
657https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-3921-39O'Niell Chambers vs. City of OremOrder of Continuance
658https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-4021-40Nate Carlise, KSTU-FOX 13 Utah vs. Beaver CountyA copy of what’s commonly known as the ‘Brady List’ maintained by Beaver County’s prosecutors.Appeal Denied
659https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-4121-41Florene Holdaway vs. Utah Department of Human ServicesA specified report filed with DCFS in July 2020.Appeal Denied
660https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-4221-42Jessica Miller, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Salt Lake City CorporationBody camera footage of a K-9 dog bite incident occurring on November 14, 2019.Appeal Denied
661https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-4321-43Center for Biological Diversity vs. Seven County Intrastructure CoalitionRecords related to the Uinta Basin Railway Project including specifically a draft financial analysis for the Uinta Basin Railway dated May 13, 2019.Appeal Denied
662https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-4421-44Brady Eames vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeRecords from the Utah Prosecution Council which is administered by the AG’s Office, and a fee waiverAppeal Denied
663https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-4521-45Mark Tracy vs. Emigration Improvement DistrictAll fire flow test results of water system 18143 owned by the District and operated by Simplifi Company since August 1, 1998.Appeal Granted
664https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-4621-46Patrick Sullivan vs. Sanpete CountyOrder of Continuance
665https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-4721-47O'Neill Chambers vs. City of OremA copy of a police report related to an incident where Mr. Chambers was the victim of an alleged assault.Appeal Denied
666https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-4821-48Lionel Trepanier vs. Utah School and Institutional Trust Lands AdministrationFee waiver for access to records.Appeal Denied
667https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-4921-49Robert Sloman vs. University of UtahAppeal Denied
668https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-5021-50Justin Sutherland vs. Utah Department of Natural ResourcesOrder of Continuance
669https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-5121-51Eric Peterson vs. Utah Department of Workforce ServicesThe names of recipients for funds spent under the Emergency Rental Assistance Program (“ERA”) for Housing Stability Services up to June 1, 2021.Appeal Denied
670https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-5221-52Adam Herbets vs. University of UtahE-mails regarding named individuals and involving specified subjects including “Fox 13” from May 15, 2021 to the present.Appeal Partially Granted
671https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-5321-53Darren Rosenstein vs. Utah Department of TransportationOrder of Continuance
672https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-5421-54Eric Peterson vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyRecords related to a protest/demonstration that took place on January 6, 2021 at the Utah State Capitol.Appeal Denied
673https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-5521-55Save Our Canyons vs. Utah Department of TransportationRecords related to the State Route 210 project in Little Cottonwood Canyon located in Salt Lake County.Appeal Granted
674https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-5621-56Brady Eames vs. Utah State TreasurerFees related to viewing records.Appeal Denied
675https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-5721-57Nicole K. Noren (ESPN) vs. University of UtahCopies of all audio and video interviews from Respondent associated with the Lauren McCluskey case.Appeal Denied
676https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-5821-58Darren Rosenstein vs. Utah Department of TransportationAppeal Denied
677https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-5921-59Jeffrey Bennion vs. Utah Housing CorporationAll materials in Respondent’s files and archives in relation to a specified individual.Appeal Denied
678https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-6021-60Scott Gollaher vs. Morgan CountyA copy of all billings received from, and payments made to, Peter Daines regarding his appellate representation of Mr. Gollaher.Order of Continuance
679https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-6121-61Nickolas Parker vs. Price City Police DepartmentOrder of Continuance
680https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=21-6221-62Mark Putnam vs. Washington County Attorney's OfficeE-mail, telephone recordings, texts, and video communications between specified individuals and the attorney prosecuting Mr. Putnam’s criminal case.Appeal Denied
681https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-0122-01Patrick Sullivan vs. Sanpete CountyRecords regarding discovery for a district court case; a request for e-mail messages, chats, or hangout messages involving specified employees of the Utah Department of Corrections; information referred to Sanpete County by the Utah Department of Corrections, Gunnison Prison.Appeal Partially Granted
682https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-0222-02Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsRecords about or in behalf of an inmate.Appeal Denied
683https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-0322-03Nickolas Parker vs. Price City Police DepartmentA copy of all annual performance evaluations, job description, classification, pay range, promotions, educational accomplishments, rewards/recognitions, department development opportunities, emails or another article that has his name on or in it and a copy of any disciplinary action including all internal affairs investigations.Appeal Partially Granted
684https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-0422-04Brian Donegan vs. Grand County Sheriff's DepartmentAny and all information relating to the murder of Kylen Schulte and Crystal Turner including type/caliber of the weapon, type of wounds, and the exact location of where the bodies had been found. IAppeal Denied
685https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-0522-05Courtney Tanner, Salt Lake Tribune vs. University of Utah & Utah System of Higher EducationAll comments submitted via the email created and operated by the Utah System of Higher Education and the public to give thoughts on the three finalists during the most recent University of Utah presidential search.Appeal Denied
686https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-0622-06Patrick Sullivan vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsA fee waiver and expedited access to initial contact reports, media statements, statistics, correspondence, and surveillance footage related to the elimination of the A/B schedule.Appeal Denied
687https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-0722-07Jonathan Bejarano vs. Utah Board of EducationOrder of Continuance
688https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-0822-08Jennifer Orton vs. Salt Lake CountyOrder of Continuance
689https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-0922-09Paul Amann vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyAny and all records regarding a specified individual, including records of applications, communications, and correspondence involving that individual.Appeal Denied
690https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-1022-10Aaron Pacini vs. Jordan School District(1) Election results for all South Jordan Elementary Community Council ("SCC") 2021-2022 elections; (2) The SCC election rules and procedures governing all SCC 2021-2022 elections; (3) The names of each SCC member including parents and teachers, the beginning dates of their service and the ending date of their current term; (4) All emails, texts, and other communications (regardless of official or personal communications) to or from South Jordan Elementary's principal, vice-principal, other administrators and office staff regarding SCC in the calendar year 2021, SCC election(s) for the year 2021-2022 and Pacini by name or reference including Aaron, Shalene, Christopher, Jacob, Timothy or Nathan; (5) All emails, texts or other communications (personal or official) from or to two specified individuals regarding the SCC 2021-2022 election including references to "Pacini," any candidate, the election process, results, etc.; and (6) The number of students in each SJE class from each Dibels category.Appeal Denied
691https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-1122-11Jonathan Bejarano vs. Utah State Board of EducationAll e-mails on Board Member Cline's Gmail from August 26, 2021 to September 29, 2021 that include one or more of the keywords "uea, critical race theory, crt, Johnson, Senator, Representative, Christiansen or UPU."Appeal Partially Granted
692https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-1222-12Jennifer Orten vs. Salt Lake CountyCommunications received by or sent by Salt Lake County Clerk Sherrie Swensen and Mark Pemberton, communications by Ms. Swensen using the words “voter roll(s)” or “canvas(ing)(ers), and a fee waiver.Appeal Partially Granted
693https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-1322-13Thomas Swell vs. University of UtahRecords from the Health Gastroenterology Endoscopy Center and Liver Clinic) between September 1, 2021 through September 30, 2021: (1) The full name, first and last, of each employee who worked a shift on each day; (2) The start time and end time of the shift for each fully named employee on each day; and (3) The team, position, assignment, role, and/or area of responsibility of each fully named employee who worked a shift on each day.Appeal Denied
694https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-1422-14Steven Onysko vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeUnredacted records.Appeal Denied
695https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-1522-15Chad Lambourne vs. Utah Highway PatrolOrder of Continuance
696https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-1622-16Ian Cooperstein vs. University of UtahCorrespondence between human resources for the University and two people regarding a complaint petitioner had previously filed.Appeal Denied
697https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-1722-17Adam Herbets vs. Unified PoliceOrder of Continuance
698https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-1822-18Adam Herbets vs. Heber City PoliceCopies of all settlement agreements, dispositions of claim, and/or nondisclosure agreements involving Heber City from January 1, 2021, through present day.Appeal Partially Approved
699https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-1922-19Adam Herbets vs. Heber City PoliceRecords of communications with a specified individual.Order of Continuance
700https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-2022-20Brady Eames vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeRecords related to the trial and conviction of Michael Anthony Archuleta for the murder of Gordon Church in 1988. Specifically, “unique information in rough notes or drafts assembled or created and used to prepare other documents [that] adds proper understanding to the formulation and execution of policies, decisions, actions, or responsibilities” of the appellate division and the Solicitor General of the AG’s Office for the Archuleta case.Appeal Denied
701https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-2122-21Mark Tracy vs. Emigration Improvement DistrictLegal invoices and evidence of payment submitted to the “EMIGRATION IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT" from the law firm of Cohne Kinghorn P.C., Parson Kinghorn and Harris P.C., and Gerald R. Kinghorn P.C. since August 1, 1998.Appeal Denied
702https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-2222-22Reginald Williams vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsResults of all covid test; cost and maker of covid test; person(s) that authorized/performed petitioner's covid test, and the reason for performing the covid test.Appeal Denied
703https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-2322-23Nate Carlisle vs. Utah Department of TransportationA copy of the report(s) Deer Valley Resort filed concerning the mechanical failure on the Carpenter Express chairlift on or about December 24, 2021.Appeal Granted
704https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-2422-24Adam Herbets vs. Unified PoliceCopies of all body camera footage of three police officers involved in two incidents. The records included body camera footage taken inside a medical facility.Appeal Denied
705https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-2522-25Adam Herbets vs. Utah County Attorney's OfficeCopies of all letters or e-mails received by the Utah County Sheriff’s Office explaining decisions by prosecutors with Respondent relating to the charging of a specified individual who was arrested in January 2022.Appeal Denied
706https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-2622-26Adam Herbets vs. Heber City PoliceOrder of Continuance
707https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-2722-27Courtney Tanner vs. University of UtahAny police reports regarding two University of Utah students, Haoyu Wang and Zhifan Dong.Appeal Granted
708https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-2822-28George Staheli vs. Utah Tech UniversityAll data the Cicero Group gathered for the Dixie State University name change process.Appeal Denied
709https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-2922-29Brady Eames vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsRecords documenting the mental health status of an inmate and accounting records documenting tax funds used to provide mental health services to him.Appeal Denied
710https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-3022-30Parents Defending Education vs. Salt Lake City School DistrictOrder of Continuance
711https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-3122-31Adam Herbets vs. Farmington CityRecords regarding a Farmington City employee: (1) Copies of all complaints filed against the employee in 2021 and 2022; (2) Copies of all attached records submitted alongside the complaints; (3) Copies of all files generated from a completed investigation; (4) Copies of all reports documenting the use of force; and (5) Copies of all electronic communication, including but not limited to emails and text messages sent by the employee and Farmington City Manager in 2022 and any responses to those sent messages.Appeal Denied
712https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-3222-32Eric Peterson vs. Department of Natural ResourcesA DNR investigative report from a 2018 hunt.Appeal Denied
713https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-3322-33Mike Brown vs. Davis School DistrictA fee waiver for records held by Respondent, the Davis School District.Appeal Denied
714https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-3422-34Eric Peterson vs. Utah Inland Port AuthorityDrafts known as "Working Papers 2".Appeal Denied
715https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-3522-35Patrick Sullivan vs. Sanpete CountyRequest limits within a calendar year.Appeal Denied
716https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-3622-36Parents Defending Education vs. Salt Lake School DistrictOrder of Continuance
717https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-3722-37Aaron Davidson vs. Alpine School DistrictA fee waiver for records held by Respondent, the Alpine School District.Appeal Denied
718https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-3822-38Eric Peterson vs. Attorney General's OfficeAttorney General Office’s review of a Department of Natural Resources investigative report from a 2018 hunt.Appeal Denied
719https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-3922-39Nickolas Parker vs. Carbon CountyInternal affairs investigation records - specifically, two email correspondence, dated May 8, 2020, and May 12, 2020, between the city attorney and employees of Respondent or the Price City Police Department.Appeal Denied
720https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-4022-40Steve Regruto vs. Carbon CountyInternal affairs investigation records - specifically, two email correspondence, dated May 8, 2020, and May 12, 2020, between the city attorney and employees of Respondent or the Price City Police Department.Appeal Denied
721https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-4122-41Michael Clara vs. Utah State Board of EducationCopies of all records that the Utah UPPAC [Utah Professional Practices Advisory Commission] members and staff created, obtained and reviewed. In addition, a fee waiver was requested.Appeal Denied
722https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-4222-42Brady Eames vs. Logan CityFee waiverAppeal Denied
723https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-4322-43Ian Cooperstein vs. Attorney General's OfficeAll of the communications that the office of the Attorney General had with employees at attorneys of the law firm of McConkie-Collinwood-Adams from December 2019 through December 2021 related to petitioner's case before the Utah Labor Commission.Appeal Denied
724https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-4422-44Patrick Sullivan vs. Sanpete CountyAll emails from a list of individuals that mentioned the petitioner, along with any attachments to those emails, that were sent from January 1, 2019, to the date of his request. Petitioner also requested a “certified copy of summons” for a specific district court case along with a signature showing the date Respondent received the document and a copy of the envelope.Order of Continuance
725https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-4522-45Raphael Cordray vs. Carbon CountyAll emails and their attachments created, received, or retained by Respondent from July 1, 2020, to the date of Respondent’s response that regarded, contained, or referenced any of the following terms pertaining to Carbon County: “Satellite Port,” “Inland Port,” “Ridge Road site,” “Price river terminal,” or “Inland Port development.”Appeal Granted, and Order of Continuance
726https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-4622-46Ian Cooperstein vs. University of UtahRecords relating to a former employee of Respondent’s (referred to hereafter as “J.G.”) in three areas: Documentation about [J.G.’s] early 2020 termination, [m]aterials related to his 2018 promotion, and information about the tuition assistance amounts and dates that he received.Appeal Denied
727https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-4722-47Nate Carlisle vs. Salt Lake County District Attorney's OfficeAny statement, and recorded interviews given and had by Mamie Reeder in conjunction with two cases prosecuted by the Salt Lake County District Attorney’s Office (“DA”): State v. Wellen, case no. 181905553, and State v. Malachowski, case no. 181903984.Appeal Denied
728https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-4822-48Azlen Marchet vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyThe results of a rape kit.Appeal Denied
729https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-4922-49Patrick Sullivan vs. Sanpete CountyAll emails from a list of individuals that mentioned him, along with any attachments to those emails, that were sent from January 1, 2019, to the date of his request. Petitioner also requested a “certified copy of summons” for a specific district court case along with a signature showing the date Respondent received the document and a copy of the envelope.Appeal Partially Granted
730https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-5022-50Wendy Halloran vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsRecords relating to a tragic accident that occurred on May 2, 2022.Appeal Partially Granted
731https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-5122-51Lynn David vs. Wasatch CountyRecords pertaining to names and addresses of all individuals who applied for primary residence exemptions for their property taxes in Wasatch County and were asked to provide evidence that they were county residents from the time period of January 1, 2016, through June 1, 2022.Appeal Denied
732https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-5222-52Raphael Cordray vs. Carbon CountyAll emails and their attachments created, received, or retained by Respondent from July 1, 2020, to the date of Respondent’s response that regarded, contained, or referenced any of the following terms pertaining to Carbon County: “Satellite Port,” “Inland Port,” “Ridge Road site,” “Price river terminal,” or “Inland Port development.”Appeal Dismissed
733https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-5322-53Lynn David vs. Wasatch CountyAll records related to a rock mining operation on lots 195 and 221 in Brighton Estates, Wasatch County, Utah, including information related to a complaint Petitioner lodged with Respondent in 2021 concerning the operation (“Complaint”), all documentation concerning the business license application and approval for the individual conducting the rock mining operation (“Business License”), and Petitioner’s own communications in with Wasatch County on the matter throughout 2022.Appeal Denied
734https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-5422-54Lynn David vs. Wasatch CountyDocumentation related to the property located at 2399 W. Boulder Dr, and lots 195, 207, 208, and 221. And all communications received between July 20, 2022, and August 24, 2022, concerning the boulder extraction operation in Brighton Estates.Appeal Denied
735https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-5522-55Lynn David vs. Wasatch CountyRecords pertaining to law enforcement’s interaction with him and others on July 22, 2022, when a resident in Brighton Estates (Wasatch County, Utah) complained to law enforcement that Petitioner had been photographing and following his employees.Appeal Denied
736https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-5622-56Paul Amann vs. Utah Attorney GeneralRecords pertaining to the investigation of a firearm left at the Hale Center Theater after the Attorney General’s Office held an office-wide meeting there in 2014.Appeal Denied
737https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-5722-57Paul Amann vs. Utah Attorney GeneralRecords pertaining to legal representation of the Respondent, any elected official of the Respondent, or any employee, agent, or appointee employed by the Respondent since December 24, 2013.Appeal Denied
738https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-5822-58Paul Amann vs. Utah Attorney GeneralRecords connected to the Respondent’s “compliance with Utah Procurement Code,” and the Respondent’s own policy regarding procurements in relation to it retaining the Ray Quinney Nebeker law firm (“RQN”) to represent it in any matter involving Petitioner.Appeal Denied
739https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-5922-59Shawn Herring vs. Vineyard CityRecords, public meeting notices, agendas, minutes, emails, documents, texts, responses and submissions, official letters and any communications regarding any proposals, requests, authorizations, letters of intent, contracts, planning, or future plans between certain named individuals from August 2017 to present.Appeal Partially Granted
740https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-6022-60Jeffrey Wetsel vs. Price City Policy DepartmentRecords surrounding a police call regarding a child custody dispute.Appeal Dismissed
741https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=22-6122-61Judith Zimmerman vs. Department of Health and Human ServicesA list of third-party entities and individuals to whom Respondent shared Petitioner’s personal information with during a specified date range.Appeal Denied
742https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-0123-01Jaime Wiley (for Jacob Allen) vs. Division of Child and Family ServicesAll reports, notes, findings, conclusions, summaries, and investigation-related records related to Jacob Allen [date of birth], , including but not limited to Case Number 2899047.Appeal Denied
743https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-0223-02Mark Tracy vs. Emigration Improvement DistrictAll legal invoices and evidence of payment submitted to Emigration Improvement District from the Salt Lake City law firm Chone Kinghorn P.C., Parson Kinghorn and Harris P.C., and Gerald R. Kinghorn P.C. since August 1, 1998. Appeal is about the fees for providing these records.Appeal Denied
744https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-0323-03Jared Pela vs. Salt Lake City School DistrictAll records of access for petitioner'ss specific parent portal, all information pertaining to any modifications of his parent portal, including additions, deletions, and changes to his individual portal, and all attendance records for his son.Appeal Denied
745https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-0423-04Daniel Herrera vs. Department of CorrectionsAll lab tests results for certain medical tests petitioner had performed on May 8, 2018, and various other medical records. Also includes communications regarding illegal activity.Order of Continuance
746https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-0523-05Anna and Bryan Baggaley vs. Granite School DistrictRecords pertaining to Granger High School’s decision to remove Petitioner, Anna Baggaley, from her 2nd period US Government Class. These records were to include “emails, meeting notes, files, complaints, written decisions, etc.Order of Continuance
747https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-0623-06Corey Coleman vs. Vernal CityTimecards of Matt Tate, a current employee of Respondent and former associate of Petitioner, for the date range of November 1, 2021 through February 1, 2022.Appeal Denied
748https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-0723-07Brady Eames vs. State TreasurerAppeal withdrawn
749https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-0823-08Courtney Tanner, Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah State University, Noelle Crockett, IntervenorAny emails sent by President Noelle Crockett from Nov. 10 [2022], to Nov. 15 [2022], about her possible departure or the football/athletic program at USU.Appeal Denied
750https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-0923-09Anna and Bryan Baggaly vs. Granite School DistrictRecords pertaining to Granger High School’s decision to remove Petitioner, Anna Baggaley, from her 2nd period US Government Class.Appeal Partially Granted
751https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-1023-10Judith Zimmerman vs. Utah Department of Health and Human ServicesAny records surrounding the petitioner's complaints about department staff, including any subsequent investigation, findings, and disciplinary action.Order of Continuation
752https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-1123-11Tim McConnehey vs. Jordan School DistrictAll emails about West Jordan Elementary from a school board member's personal email account.Appeal Granted
753https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-1223-12Brady Eames vs. Logan CityRecords in connection to the construction of the Logan City Plaza & Event Stage, including the general contract awarded to the construction company, proof of liability and workers compensation insurance provided by the construction company, receipt of donated private funds for the project, and documentation of the use of public funds to compensate the construction company.Appeal Denied
754https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-1323-13Ian Cooperstein vs. University of UtahJob posting materials for a job posting that Petitioner claims was labeled “Personal Training Supervisor” and was posted from August 2015 until July 2019.Appeal Partially Granted
755https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-1423-14Paul Amann vs. Office of the Utah Attorney GeneralAll records concerning the Respondent’s disciplinary action taken against its employees from January 2014 through the date of the records request.Appeal Denied
756https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-1523-15Courtney Tanner (Salt Lake Tribune) vs. Utah System of Higher EducationAny communication between and among members of the Utah Board of Higher Education, the USHE commissioner and/or his executive team and/or Utah State University President Noelle Crockett about Crockett’s tenure, concerns about her administration and/or her departure as president and any agreements about what that would look like.Order of Continuation
757https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-1623-16Marlon Smith vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyIncident reports, videos from dash and body cameras, dispatch records, and policies and procedures regarding an incident.Appeal Denied
758https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-1723-17Jennifer Lewis vs. Austin Community Special Service DistrictA copy of the digital recording (as well as resolutions adopted) of the regular meeting of the Administrative Control Board of the Austin Community Special Service District held on Tuesday, October 18, 2022, at 35 West Main, Elsinore, UT, at the hour of 6:30 pm; a copy of the budget hearing minutes from June 29, 2022, as approved by the board and referenced as “agenda item (1)” of the regular meeting of the Administrative Control Board of the Austin Community Special Service District on October 18, 2022; and records relating to water services. Also requesting a fee waiver.Appeal Granted
759https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-1823-18Cindy O'Neil vs. East Carbon CityA copy of all applications for service that have been submitted to the city for the connection at 178 West Geneva pertaining to certain named tenants; minutes of the Board of Equalization; and all records concerning rebates, refunds, or charges that were forgiven or dropped by the city for the last 3 years pursuant to city code.Appeal Partially Granted
760https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-1923-19Judith Zimmerman vs. Utah Department of Health and Human ServicesAny records surrounding the petitioner's complaints about department staff, including any subsequent investigation, findings, and disciplinary action.Appeal Denied
761https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-2023-20Nicholas Bender (on behalf of the Johnson family) vs. Uintah School DistrictAll (electronic and hard copy) documents, materials, records, photos, videos, recordings, communications, notes, incident reports, evaluations, and like records and information related to the playground incident involving a student at Discovery Elementary on April 7, 2022.Appeal Partially Granted
762https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-2123-21Gregory Ferbrache vs. Utah State Tax CommissionAny and all records relating to the investigation of Bonneville Equipment, and/or Steve Dabb, Scott Pruyt and/or Monika Griff to include but limited to audio recordings, video recordings, photographs, reports, documents, emails, text messages, notes, subpoenas, affidavits, memorandums, charts and/or power points.Appeal Denied
763https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-2223-22Annie Knox vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeAG Reyes’ weekly schedule/calendar for August 2022 to date.Appeal Granted
764https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-2323-23C. Peter Sorensen vs. Salt Lake City Police DepartmentOrder of Continuance
765https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-2423-24Daniel Herrera vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAppeal Dismissed
766https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-2523-25Courtney Johns vs. Utah County Sheriff's OfficeUtah County Jail’s visitor log for Jonathan Soberanis.Appeal Granted
767https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-2623-26Diane Allen vs. Davis CountyAll records of communications by and between employees of Davis County, Davis County Justice Court, Davis County Prosecutor's office including phone calls, recordings, text messages, emails, written documents involving or mentioning Diane Allan, Diane Killian Allan or Diane Killian Allen.Appeal Denied
768https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-2723-27Adam Herbets (Fox 13) vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsAll electronic communication, including, but not limited to, emails and text messages between Wasatch County Sheriff, Jared Rigby, and Brian Nielson from June 30, 2022, through present day.Appeal Granted
769https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-2823-28Courtney Tanner (Salt Lake Tribune) vs. Utah System of Higher EducationAny communication between and among members of the Utah Board of Higher Education, the USHE commissioner and/or his executive team and/or Utah State University President Noelle Crockett about Crockett’s tenure, concerns about her administration and/or her departure as president and any agreements about what that would look like.Appeal Partially Granted
770https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-2923-29Ken Walker vs. Utah CountyAnonymized electronic copy of each individual cast ballot and/or cast vote record(s) or equivalent information maintained by Utah County for the City of Moab general election held on Nov. 2, 2021.Order of Continuation
771https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-3023-30Carl Fleming vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsThe “inmate log for SMU suicide watch cells,” including “how many inmates were placed in cell #3” from August 27, 2022 through September 14, 2022.Appeal Partially Granted
772https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-3123-31Taylor Barnes (Inkstick Media) vs. Governor's Office of Economic Opportunity Northrup Grumman Systems Corporation, interested partyThe Economic Development Agreement for the tax credits offered to Northrop Grumman for the Ground-Based Deterrent.Appeal Denied
773https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-3223-32Eric Peterson (Utah Investigative Journalism Project) vs. Salt Lake City Police DepartmentFull unredacted report into the homicide investigation of Joseph Salas found in the Jordan River near North Temple on June 9, 2021.Appeal Denied
774https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-3323-33Jack Widdison vs. Mount Pleasant CityA copy of the recording of the Mt. Pleasant City closed meeting that was held on July 12, 2022, in which Petitioner was a topic of discussion.Appeal Denied
775https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-3423-34Adam Herbets vs. Utah Governor's OfficeCopies of all electronic communication, including but not limited to emails and text messages sent or received by Utah Governor’s Office employees (including the governor) related to Jared Rigby between January 1, 2022, and present day, plus any responses to those messages. Also messages referencing "Herbets, Herberts, Fox13, or Fox 13" since December 19, 2022.Appeal Denied
776https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-3523-35Ian Cooperstein vs. University of UtahAll communication between Mary Bohlig, director of Campus Recreation Services, and Diane Dahlman that relate to me that were communicated through University accounts from 2008-2019.Appeal Granted
777https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-3623-36Shana Kummer vs. Sevier County School DistrictVideo of a physical education class held at South Sevier Middle School.Appeal Granted
778https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-3723-37Brady Eames vs. Utah State TreasurerCertain transactional reports and pro-rata shares from the Public Treasurers’ Investment Fund in connection with a number of public entities for certain months throughout 2022. Petitioner also asked for a fee waiver.Appeal Denied
779https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-3823-38Jonathan Bejarano vs. Utah State TreasurerDigital copy of all the e-mails sent or received by Marlo Oaks from August 1, 2022, to September 1, 2022, that contained the keyword ‘Blackrock.’ Additionally, Petitioner requested a fee waiver for any applicable fees.Appeal Denied
780https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-3923-39Paul Amann vs. Division of Risk ManagementRecords of any payments (including invoices) to certain individuals, and/or the law firm of Ray Quinney and Nebeker; records about a $250,000 payment from the Utah Attorney General's Office; and correspondence between the Utah Attorney General's Office and the Division of Risk Management regarding petitioner.Appeal Partially Granted
781https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-4023-40Steven Boos vs. San Juan CountyOrder of Continuance
782https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-4123-41Paul Amann vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeHiring records related to the section chief positions, incuding interview notes.Appeal Denied
783https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-4223-42Brady Eames vs. Utah Department of Financial Institutions“Public Funds Monthly Reports” submitted to the Respondent by Zions Bank, Wells Fargo Bank, and Cache Valley Bank with respect to the public funds deposited by the State Treasurer and various local governments in Cache County.Appeal Denied
784https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-4323-43Brady Eames vs. Utah System of Higher EducationDocumentation of the appointment or hiring of certain persons by Dave Woolstenhulme as his professional, legal, and administrative staff; documentation in which he made a determination or setting of the salary, retirement provisions and other benefits pertaining to staff; and issues related to taking an oath of office.Appeal Denied
785https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-4423-44Shaun Lucas vs. Box Elder CountyCost data referred to in Standard 6.6.9 of the Real Property Valuations Standards of Practice issued by the Utah State Tax Commission.Appeal Denied
786https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-4523-45David Reymann (Utah Investigative Journalism Project) vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyAll records Utah Police Officer Standards and Training (“POST”) had relating to law enforcement officer certification in Utah.Appeal Granted
787https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-4623-46Paul Amann vs. Division of Risk ManagementReconsideration of Decision and Order, case no. 23-39 (entered Aug. 28, 2023)Appeal Denied
788https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-4723-47ITV America vs. Salt Lake County Sheriff's OfficeThe “audio of the jail calls placed by Janie Lynn Ridd” that were made from the Salt Lake County Adult Detention Center on certain dates in December 2019 and January 2020.Appeal Granted
789https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-4823-48Ty Winterton vs. Duchesne CountyCamera footage from inside and outside the Centennial Center arena.Appeal Denied
790https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-4923-49Steven Boos vs. San Juan CountySixty-one total items that related to Respondent allegedly releasing emails that were private and confidential under attorney-client privilege without authorization.Appeal Denied
791https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-5023-50Corey Coleman vs. Uintah County and Vernal CityRecords relating to the 2019 charges filed against petitioner by respondent, namely: All text messages for Tegan Troutner (Uintah County prosecutor’s office) from September 16, 2022, through September 23, 2022;. a copy of the investigation report; any communication regarding the case; text communications from and to Tegan Troutner on September 20, 2022 through September 22, 2022; any texts and emails from Cameron Beach, Tegan Troutner, Vernal City, Greg Lamb, Jaymon Thomas, ABH Law etc., from January 2019 through September 2019; and an email to or from Greg Lamb containing 200 plus photos and attachments.Order of Continuation
792https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-5123-51Emily Anderson Stern (Salt Lake Tribune) vs. University of UtahAll reports of alleged sexual harassment or misconduct experienced by students in connection with the internships through the Hinckley Institute of Politics and given to the Respondent or its employees from Jan. 1, 2013, to the present; documentation of any actions taken by the Respondent after receiving such information,Appeal Denied
793https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-5223-52Luis Sanchez vs. Salt Lake City Police DepartmentAll audio recordings, video recordings (including handheld cameras, body-worn cameras and any other video recordings), police reports, witness statements, and any and every other document and file created regarding the July 9, 2020, protest of Bernardo Palacios’ murder; video audit trails, and identifiers of responding officers.Appeal Denied
794https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-5323-53Courtney Tanner (Salt Lake Tribune) vs. Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Child and Family ServicesThe external review or fatality review and related docs, responses conducted on how Utah DCFS handled the Haight family case in Enoch.Appeal Denied
795https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-5423-54Courtney John (ABC 4 News) vs. Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Child and Family ServicesAny audio, video, or images collected involving Michael Haight’s abuse allegations.Appeal Denied
796https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-5523-55Dennis Romboy (Deseret News) vs. University of Utah, Utah State University, Weber State University, Utah Valley University, and Southern Utah UniversityCopies of all "Name, Image, and Likeness" (NIL) contracts and written agreements' submitted from January 2022 to the present. Petitioner also requested “the compliance office’s response to the [contracts’] submission, whether it was approved or disapproved, and any documentation accompanying the response.”Appeal Granted
797https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-5623-56Corey Coleman vs. Uintah County and Vernal CityAll text messages for Tegan Troutner (Uintah County prosecutor’s office) from September 16, 2022, through September 23, 2022; a copy of the investigation report; any communication regarding the case; text communications from and to Tegan Troutner on September 20, 2022 through September 22, 2022; any texts and emails from Cameron Beach, Tegan Troutner, Vernal City, Greg Lamb, Jaymon Thomas, ABH Law etc., from January 2019 through September 2019; and an email to or from Greg Lamb containing 200 plus photos and attachments.Appeal Denied
798https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-5723-57Luiz Sanchez vs. Utah Department of Public SafetyAll records related to Jared Brooks Cardon’s traffic accident of June 21, 2021.Appeal Denied
799https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-5823-58Michael Rowley vs. Utah Department of Workforce ServicesA copy of petitioner's former employer’s response, statement, and/or transcript to the filing for unemployment and the employer’s stated reason as to why he was no longer employed by them.Appeal Denied
800https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-5923-59Jared Kummer vs. Sevier County School DistrictRecords related to physical education classes at South Sevier Middle School.Order of Continuance
801https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-6023-60Office of the Utah State Treasurer vs. Brady EamesThe Petitioner must determine whether Respondent is a vexatious requester under Section 63G-2-209, and, if so, the proper amount of time which the Petitioner, including its various divisions, public bodies, and entities, need not respond to Respondent’s records requests.Appeal Granted
802https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-6123-61Michael Clara vs. Utah State Board of EducationRecords related to investigation of a board member regarding social media posts.Appeal Denied
803https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-6223-62Lynn David vs. Wasatch CountyWritten complaints received by Wasatch County from the public or another governmental entity concerning any activities of Wasatch County from 2015-2023.Appeal Denied
804https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-6323-63Hughes General Contractors (Joe McAllister) vs. Wasatch School District and Westland Construction, Intervenor, Interested PartySubcontractor documents.Appeal Granted
805https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=23-6423-64Jared Kummer vs. Sevier County School DistrictComplaints about physical education classes at South Sevier Middle School.Appeal Partially Granted
806https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=24-0624-06Alisha Ellington vs. Department of Health and Human ServicesEmail, chats, and other correspondence concerning Petitioner's employment, as well as FMLA and ADA accommodation request.Appeal Denied
807https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=24-0724-07Brady Eames vs. Utah Lieutenant Governor's OfficeThe “Official Signature Sheet for Bills and Resolutions State of Utah” pertaining to S.B. 111 (2020), S.B. 181 (2021), and S.B. 146 (2023), and a fee waiver.Appeal Denied
808https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=24-0824-08Brady Eames vs. Lehi CityThe "statutorily required public biannual report that reveals the public funds deposited and pooled in the [Public Treasurer’s Investment Fund] by the public treasurer of [Lehi City Municipal Corporation] for investment by the State Treasurer as of June 30, 2023 (D&I Report),” as well as a fee waiver.Order of Continuance
809https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=24-0924-09Brady Eames vs. Utah League of Cities and TownsRecords showing the deposit and investment report that pertains to the time period January 1, 2023 to June 30, 2023 and that was made by the public treasurer of the [Utah League of Cities and Towns] (Report). Appeal Denied
810https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=24-1024-10Brady Eames vs. Utah Local Government TrustAppeal Dismissed
811https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=24-1124-11Brady Eames vs. West Valley CityThe “statutorily required public biannual report that reveals the public funds deposited and pooled in the [Public Treasurer’s Investment Fund] by the public treasurer of [West Valley City Municipal Corporation] for investment by the State Treasurer as of June 30, 2023 (D&I Report),” as well as a fee waiver.Appeal Denied
812https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=24-1224-12Ian Cooperstein vs. University of UtahJob posting materials for a job posting that Petitioner claims was labeled "Personal Training Supervisor" and was posted from August 2015 until July 2019.Appeal Granted
813https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions?decision=24-1324-13Ian Cooperstein vs. University of UtahAll communication between Mary Bohlig, director of Campus Recreation Services, and Diane Dahlman that relate to me that were communicated through University accounts from 2008-2019.Partially Granted
814https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-1424-14Ian Cooperstein vs. University of UtahRecords related to an Office of Equal Opportunity (OEO) hearing regarding Mary Bohlig.Appeal Denied
815https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-1524-15Miki Mullor vs. Town of HideoutEmails sent by Jan McCosh, the respondent's administrator, from July 2023 to the present. Also, a fee waiver request.Appeal Denied
816https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-1624-16Courtney Tanner vs. Utah System of Higher EducationAll complaints submitted to the Respondent, as well as any findings/investigations on those complaints, about alleged misconduct by Commissioner David Woolstenhulme from August 1,2021 to August 30, 2023. Any separation agreement, resignation agreement, and letter of resignation submitted and/or signed by David Woolstenhulme. All communications (including emails, texts, instant messages) sent and received Utah Board of Higher Education members and/or administrators around allegations of misconduct by Commissioner David Woolstenhulme from January 1,2022 to August 30, 2023.Order of Continuance
817https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-1724-17Courtney Tanner vs. Utah State UniversityAny/all complaints that may have been submitted/filed to Utah State University (such as HR, Title IX, Office of Equity, etc.) about Utah System of Higher Education Commissioner David Woolstenhulme, as well as any findings or investigative reports on those matters.Appeal Denied
818https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-1824-18Michael Turley vs. Utah Division of Human Resource ManagementRecords related to an investigation of the petitioner.Appeal Partially Granted
819https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-1924-19Emmanuel Carranza vs. Department of CorrectionsThe documentation/information and/or rational information that exists to demonstrate the greater degree of supervision required from approximately April 19, 2023.Appeal Denied
820https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-2024-20Jack Brewer vs. Uintah CountyAll records cross referencing or pertaining to 2023 "PhenomeCon"--a conference that takes place in Vernal, Utah, with a centralized focus on paranormal phenomena.Appeal Granted
821https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-2124-21Brady Eames vs. Logan CityCity bank records, crime reports, and documentation of funds transferred to the State Treasurer.Appeal Denied
822https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-2224-22Logan City vs. Brady EamesOrder declaring Brady Eames a vexatious requester.Appeal Granted
823https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-2324-23Courtney Tanner vs. Utah System of Higher EducationAll complaints submitted to the Respondent, as well as any findings/investigations on those complaints, about alleged misconduct by Commissioner David Woolstenhulme from August 1,2021 to August 30, 2023. Any separation agreement, resignation agreement, and letter of resignation submitted and/or signed by David Woolstenhulme. All communications (including emails, texts, instant messages) sent and received Utah Board of Higher Education members and/or administrators around allegations of misconduct by Commissioner David Woolstenhulme from January 1,2022 to August 30, 2023.Appeal Partially Granted
824https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-2424-24Kevin Call (for Andrew Figorski) v. Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Child and Family ServicesAll documents (activity records, child and family team notes, interview notes, photographs, etc.) related to Case No. 3033485.1.Appeal Granted
825https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-2524-25William Carless vs. Provo City PoliceAny investigative files pertaining to investigations of Craig Deleeuw Robertson; and any and all bodycam footage from the incident at Robertson’s home on August 9, 2023.Appeal Denied
826https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-2624-26Corey Coleman vs. Vernal CityFee waiver regarding copy machine records for planning copy machine from May 1, 2019, to May 12, 2019.Appeal Granted
827https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-2724-27Jared Kummer vs. Sevier School DistrictA copy of the redacted surveillance footage from [Eric Baker's] period 1 class on 11/17/22, where students are redacted, but educators and aids are not.Order of Continuance
828https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-2824-28Jessica Miller vs. Utah Attorney General's OfficeThe calendar of Attorney General Sean Reyes.Appeal Granted
829https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-2924-29Adam Herbets vs. Utah CountyInitial contact reports for any case in which Mary Hall and Kira Lynch (aka Kira Green) are interviewed as alleged victims of Tim Ballard.Appeal Denied
830https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-3024-30Jared Kummer vs. Sevier School DistrictA copy of the redacted surveillance footage from [Eric Baker's] period 1 class on 11/17/22, where students are redacted, but educators and aids are not.Order of Continuance
831https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-3124-31Brady Eames vs. Vernal CityFee waiver to view a financial reportAppeal Granted
832https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-3224-32Michael Clara vs. Utah State Board of EducationAll email and text correspondence respondent had (to, from, cc, bcc, including attachments) with anyone in reference to petitioner's records request of September 7, 2023 (board member Boggess and Green emails) for the period of 09/06/2021 to 09/24/2021.Appeal Denied
833https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-3324-33Shaun Lucas vs. Utah State Tax CommissionCopies of the real property tax surveys and comparable sales data from the Multiple Listing Services ("MLS") that the Respondent used to prepare its assessment/sales ratio studies for 2021, 2022, and 2023.Appeal Denied
834https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-3424-34Brady Eames vs. Utah School and Institutional Trust Fun OfficeFee waiverAppeal Granted
835https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-3524-35Miki Mullor vs. Town of HideoutResponses to a Request for Information (RFI) issued by the Town of HideoutAppeal Denied
836https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-3624-36Douglas Hulse vs. Utah Department of CorrectionsOrder of Continuance
837https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-3724-37Corey Coleman vs. Vernal CityTime sheets referenced in a court case.Appeal Granted
838https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-3824-38Corey Coleman vs. Vernal CityAccount ledgers, receipts, invoices, and contracts.Appeal Granted
839https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-3924-39Brady Eames vs. Department of Veterans and Military AffairsThe semiannual deposit and investment report pertaining to the Utah Public Treasurers Investment Fund ("PTIF") for the time period ending June 30, 2023, that has been filed with the SMMC; and each separate monthly Statement of Account that pertains to the public state money transferred by the Public Treasurer to the State Treasurer and pooled in the PTIF investment by the State Treasurer.Appeal Denied
840https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-4024-40Sydnee Gonzalez vs. Utah Department of Workforce ServicesEmails and other communications from 5/1/23 through 7/31/23 regarding Utah's Medicaid unwinding plan or Medicaid enrollment.Order of Continuance
841https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-4124-41Claire Westenhaver-Loretz and Jerry Kingston vs. Unified Police DepartmentOrder of Continuance
842https://archives.utah.gov/transparency-services/state-records-committee/src-decisions/?decision=24-4224-42Tyler Winterton vs. Utah State Tax CommissionA list of all names and mailing addresses of business (non-individual) taxpayers that the Utah State Tax Commission has initiated sales or use tax audit proceedings against in the years 2022 or 2023.Appeal Denied